Callie Graphics

new EDF install issue...

Collapse
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • jasmith41
    EDF-obsessed
    • Sep 2021
    • 316
    • AZ and NE Ohio
    • Send PM

    #1

    new EDF install issue...

    I bought JP Hobby 70mm counter-rotating fans for my B1 bomber and upgrade the ESCs to Spektrum 130s, got everything installed, fans rotating in the right direction, etc., but when I pour the coals to them they start this weird like 'clipping' / cutting out thing. It's a long way from the ESCs to the single battery and the wiring isn't just one continuous wire for the pos and neg - I've got 6" Spektrum pre-made extensions with a Spektrum Y-connector at the top to bring both ESCs into one battery. I had to solder new ends on the Y-connector to adapt it for what i needed, but all the went well...
    Based on all of the foregoing, does anyone have any thoughts on what may be happening here? Any constructive advice would be very welcomed... and thanks in advance....
  • Evan D
    I'll fly anything

    • Jan 2016
    • 5385
    • Charlotte
    • Send PM

    #2
    May be timing. Lower it.

    Comment

    • xviper
      Hobby Squawk Regular

      • Jan 2014
      • 8750
      • Calgary, Canada
      • Send PM

      #3
      Can you tell if it's one motor or both? Does it do it on the ground? Did it do it when stock? Long wire runs shouldn't cause what you're experiencing. I have several EDFs with long wire runs and none do that. Do any of the connections feel hot after a run? Maybe check the soldering in the connections. Did you calibrate the ESCs?
      Also Spektrum ESCs have a different way of doing reverse. (Are you using a Spektrum "smart" RX?) They don't use the typical reverse wire to an empty channel. Do you have reverse programmed? 2 separate Spek ESCs with reverse can be "odd". Their latest EDFs with reverse use integrated "dual" ESCs to avoid any such issues.

      Comment

      • jasmith41
        EDF-obsessed
        • Sep 2021
        • 316
        • AZ and NE Ohio
        • Send PM

        #4
        Originally posted by xviper
        Can you tell if it's one motor or both? BOTHDoes it do it on the ground? I'VE NOT FLOWN IT YET WITH THE NEW FANS AND ESCs. I Did it do it when stock? NO, BUT STOCK WERE THE STOCK 80 AMP ESCs AND FANS. Long wire runs shouldn't cause what you're experiencing. I have several EDFs with long wire runs and none do that. Do any of the connections feel hot after a run? Maybe check the soldering in the connections. Did you calibrate the ESCs? NO. I WILL TRY THAT AND ADVISE.
        Also Spektrum ESCs have a different way of doing reverse. (Are you using a Spektrum "smart" RX?) YES. They don't use the typical reverse wire to an empty channel. COPY - I KNOW. Do you have reverse programmed? NO, NOT YET. 2 separate Spek ESCs with reverse can be "odd". Their latest EDFs with reverse use integrated "dual" ESCs to avoid any such issues.
        Thanks so much for the reply - i appreciate it. I'm going to check these things you suggested... Will advise...

        Comment

        • jasmith41
          EDF-obsessed
          • Sep 2021
          • 316
          • AZ and NE Ohio
          • Send PM

          #5
          Originally posted by Evan D
          May be timing. Lower it.
          Thanks Evan - I will give that a whirl and advise...

          Comment

          • jasmith41
            EDF-obsessed
            • Sep 2021
            • 316
            • AZ and NE Ohio
            • Send PM

            #6
            Guys, I tried all of the above suggestions and nothing changed - it's still clipping above about 25-30% throttle... very strange.

            Comment

            • xviper
              Hobby Squawk Regular

              • Jan 2014
              • 8750
              • Calgary, Canada
              • Send PM

              #7
              Strange indeed. Another suggestion ................. disable one ESC at a time and see if each motor clips by itself. IE, remove one throttle lead from the RX and see what a single ESC/motor does.

              Comment

              • jasmith41
                EDF-obsessed
                • Sep 2021
                • 316
                • AZ and NE Ohio
                • Send PM

                #8
                The JP EDFs aren't compatible with the Spektrum ESCs... the JPs are 12 pole motors - that's apparently the issue...
                Thanks again for jumping in on this one. I appreciate it!

                Comment

                Working...