Drive shaft bearings for Henglong

Collapse
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Jpaw33
    Member
    • Jan 2023
    • 42
    • Ashford, CT.
    • Send PM

    #1

    Drive shaft bearings for Henglong

    Updating my Heng long Panther G 3879 with Mato metal tracks, sprocket and idler. Has anyone used driveshaft bearings. They look like they would stop a lot wobble and add some support to the driveshaft.
    The reviews on the plastic ones said they arrived cracked and the seller said it’s normal, so the all metal looks interesting.
    Thanks,Jpaw.
    Click image for larger version  Name:	07EE5EB0-8504-406E-A9CE-21C7F42A940F.jpg Views:	4 Size:	48.6 KB ID:	372485 Click image for larger version

Name:	15936DED-B462-4C4F-AFFE-F0EBB825E5D4.jpg
Views:	1426
Size:	84.5 KB
ID:	372487
  • cmdrcody
    "Grumpy"
    • Dec 2022
    • 228
    • Largo, FL USA
    • Send PM

    #2
    I've put drive shaft bearings on all my tanks that have metal tracks due to the extra strain on the drive sprocket. Also helps alot with keeping the track not jumping off.

    Click image for larger version

Name:	20230302_182852.jpg
Views:	1460
Size:	71.9 KB
ID:	372489Click image for larger version

Name:	0116231650_HDR.jpg
Views:	1408
Size:	73.3 KB
ID:	372490Click image for larger version

Name:	1222222043a.jpg
Views:	1315
Size:	86.5 KB
ID:	372491

    Comment

    • Jpaw33
      Member
      • Jan 2023
      • 42
      • Ashford, CT.
      • Send PM

      #3
      Originally posted by cmdrcody
      I've put drive shaft bearings on all my tanks that have metal tracks due to the extra strain on the drive sprocket. Also helps alot with keeping the track not jumping off.
      Do you get them locally or Ali Express??
      thanks

      Comment

      • cmdrcody
        "Grumpy"
        • Dec 2022
        • 228
        • Largo, FL USA
        • Send PM

        #4
        The axle bearings are 8mm x 12mm x 3.5mm flanged sealed bearings. Google 8 x 12 x 3.5 flanged sealed bearings. Can't remember exactly whom I purchased them from. It was either Walmart, Amazon or Ebay. They are very inexpensive to purchased.

        Comment

        • Jpaw33
          Member
          • Jan 2023
          • 42
          • Ashford, CT.
          • Send PM

          #5
          Originally posted by cmdrcody
          The axle bearings are 8mm x 12mm x 3.5mm flanged sealed bearings. Google 8 x 12 x 3.5 flanged sealed bearings. Can't remember exactly whom I purchased them from. It was either Walmart, Amazon or Ebay. They are very inexpensive to purchased.
          Thanks, how would I attach these to the hull, I know they slide over the shaft, but since it’s just the bearing without a housing, unlike the Ali Express 2 piece, do I epoxy the outer edge of the bearing to the hull? I appreciate the help.
          Jpaw
          Click image for larger version  Name:	185A4446-96CC-47EE-9C1F-3064B0870C98.jpg Views:	0 Size:	66.6 KB ID:	372499Click image for larger version  Name:	547DAB6C-DF91-4DDD-A5B1-436ACA1ED023.jpg Views:	0 Size:	7.1 KB ID:	372498

          Comment

          • tank_me
            Senior Member

            • Feb 2022
            • 1182
            • Send PM

            #6
            Normally they just press fit in.

            Derek

            Comment

            • Jpaw33
              Member
              • Jan 2023
              • 42
              • Ashford, CT.
              • Send PM

              #7
              Originally posted by tank_me
              Normally they just press fit in.

              Derek
              Got it! Flange end out.

              Comment

              • cmdrcody
                "Grumpy"
                • Dec 2022
                • 228
                • Largo, FL USA
                • Send PM

                #8
                Depending on the chassis, you may have to very carefully with a dremil tool, open the diameter of the hole just enough to get a light press fit for the bearing and use a very very light film of adhesive to the outer side of the bearing.

                Comment

                • keilau
                  Senior Member

                  • Mar 2021
                  • 1815
                  • Windy City
                  • Send PM

                  #9
                  Originally posted by cmdrcody
                  Depending on the chassis, you may have to very carefully with a dremil tool, open the diameter of the hole just enough to get a light press fit for the bearing and use a very very light film of adhesive to the outer side of the bearing.
                  After I install the metal bearing drive shaft cover on the Leopard 2A6, I found that it runs but the alignment is not perfect. I loosened the gearbox and tightened it again. There is no play to adjust the cover and I don't like the idea of grinding it.

                  I like the metal bearing drive shaft cover a lot in improving the alignment and integrity of the gearbox. The original HL plastic cover was cosmetic only with 2 screws. My comment applies to the HL Leopard 2A6 only.

                  Comment

                  • Rubicon99
                    Senior Member

                    • Dec 2019
                    • 3311
                    • Send PM

                    #10
                    Originally posted by keilau

                    After I install the metal bearing drive shaft cover on the Leopard 2A6, I found that it runs but the alignment is not perfect. I loosened the gearbox and tightened it again. There is no play to adjust the cover and I don't like the idea of grinding it.

                    I like the metal bearing drive shaft cover a lot in improving the alignment and integrity of the gearbox. The original HL plastic cover was cosmetic only with 2 screws. My comment applies to the HL Leopard 2A6 only.
                    When say alignment are you saying the drive shaft is no longer straight or does it appear to be wobbling? Or are you saying that the sprockets appear out of alignment or are wobbling?

                    Adding the axle support bears should not have changed anything in regards to gearbox alignment. All they do is support the drive axle to help keep it from wobbling. If you have wobble after the bearings are added then most likely the drive shaft(s) was bent prior to the installation of the bearings. Very common to see. There is a tendency to see the wobble more after installation of the bearings then before, because now there is no "free play" space for the axle to move within hiding the wobble. All movement is now (with bearings) more sharply translated to the sprocket and hull.

                    If this is you case there are on three options. Live with the wobble, replacing the drive shaft(s) or buy a completely new/upgrade transmission.

                    If the shaft are not wobbling then your issue is the sprocket. These can a do bend or are molded poorly. Again the issues become more obvious when bearings are added. The simplest solution is to replace the sprocket but that too is a gamble because you might get another set with similar issues. The last solution I could offer is for you to add a small thin rubber "D" ring to the inside of the sprocket where the axle meets the sprocket hub. These tend to balance out of spec sprocket rather well and should not effect reliably.

                    Comment

                    • keilau
                      Senior Member

                      • Mar 2021
                      • 1815
                      • Windy City
                      • Send PM

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Rubicon99

                      When say alignment are you saying the drive shaft is no longer straight or does it appear to be wobbling? Or are you saying that the sprockets appear out of alignment or are wobbling?

                      Adding the axle support bears should not have changed anything in regards to gearbox alignment. All they do is support the drive axle to help keep it from wobbling. If you have wobble after the bearings are added then most likely the drive shaft(s) was bent prior to the installation of the bearings. Very common to see. There is a tendency to see the wobble more after installation of the bearings then before, because now there is no "free play" space for the axle to move within hiding the wobble. All movement is now (with bearings) more sharply translated to the sprocket and hull.

                      If this is you case there are on three options. Live with the wobble, replacing the drive shaft(s) or buy a completely new/upgrade transmission.

                      If the shaft are not wobbling then your issue is the sprocket. These can a do bend or are molded poorly. Again the issues become more obvious when bearings are added. The simplest solution is to replace the sprocket but that too is a gamble because you might get another set with similar issues. The last solution I could offer is for you to add a small thin rubber "D" ring to the inside of the sprocket where the axle meets the sprocket hub. These tend to balance out of spec sprocket rather well and should not effect reliably.
                      The Heng Long tank drive shaft has very good alignment. It may allow a small fraction of a degree off from perpendicular to the moving direction which is well within the tolerance of any plastic tank chassis. I cannot detect any wobbling or track noise as was. The outer bearing on the cover is a tight friction fit and impose a more exact alignment of the gearbox. Since I installed the gearbox first, the very tiny amount of off-alignment was detected. I just loosened the gearbox and tightened them again. That's the beauty of the metal bearing drive shaft cover design. It is self aligned.

                      I have the very tight tolerance Heng Xin ball bearing gearbox which allowed the small misalignment to be detected. I suspeect that if I had the HL sleeve bearing gearbox, there would be enough play in the drive shaft that the adjustment would not be necessary.

                      Comment

                      • keilau
                        Senior Member

                        • Mar 2021
                        • 1815
                        • Windy City
                        • Send PM

                        #12
                        The German Leopard is the first HL I purchased after 3 HL tanks in the mid 2000's. (I also purchased the T34 and Sherman since.) Some of you may see how I gashed about the improvement in quality and ease of upgradee. The tank upper and lower half practically fell into place after any internal upgrade.

                        After I installed the metal bearing drive shaft cover on the Leopard 2A6, I ran many tests with the top only sitting on top to make sure that it runs smoothly. It took me another 2 days to buttom up the 2 halfs. In addition to the 6 screw poles, the 2A6 has tab and hood at the back and sidewalls on the side to guide the final assembly. The addition of the shaft cover made the alignment more demanding. It took me many tries to get them ALL line up at the same time. The final result is very rewarding. @cmdrcody​ upgraded the same 2A6 cover. I did not see him having the same difficulty.

                        Comment

                        • keilau
                          Senior Member

                          • Mar 2021
                          • 1815
                          • Windy City
                          • Send PM

                          #13
                          I got this single bearing shaft cover from ToucanHobby and am very happy with its fit and quality. No specific manufacturer was mentioned.
                          https://www.ebay.com/itm/224860217656
                          Coupled with the gearbox ball bearing on the inside end of the drive shaft, it forms a perfect support with no play.

                          Originally posted by keilau
                          The bearing on the cover is a tight friction fit and impose a more exact alignment of the gearbox. Since I installed the gearbox first, the very tiny amount of off-alignment was detected. I just loosened the gearbox and tightened them again. That's the beauty of the metal bearing drive shaft cover design. It is self aligned.
                          The bearing was press fit into the cover first. Since it is polished steel on steel, the bearing slided down the shaft with only a small hint of friction. The left side cover lined up perfectly. I align the screw holes and tighten them up. The right cover was off center and tilted to the side wall slightly. To me, it was an indication that the right side gearbox was NOT aligned correctly. Loosening up the gearbox and the cover fell in place. I ran the motor gearbox a few times at high speed before I tightened everything up. That's what I called self-alignment.

                          I was a Mechanical engineer at the aerospace industry spending time in the office, laboratory and factory floor. I can feel the tightness of fit and bearing easily. This bearing shaft cover is a good investment if you want more smooth running tank.

                          Comment

                          • hblake1427
                            Member
                            • Aug 2022
                            • 13
                            • Send PM

                            #14
                            Adding on to this thread, does anyone have a source for a T-34 bearing set? I've looked all over and can't find any.

                            I see the 8x12x3.5 bearings mentioned above, anyone have experience with that size in a T-34 hull?

                            Comment

                            • Rubicon99
                              Senior Member

                              • Dec 2019
                              • 3311
                              • Send PM

                              #15
                              Originally posted by hblake1427
                              Adding on to this thread, does anyone have a source for a T-34 bearing set? I've looked all over and can't find any.

                              I see the 8x12x3.5 bearings mentioned above, anyone have experience with that size in a T-34 hull?
                              The T34 is the one tank HL makes that does not need bearing supports so none have been made except the "one offs" by individuals here and there. Its just a tank that can operate very very well with a loose tolerance and sloppy tracks.


                              Comment

                              • MrChef
                                Member

                                • Jan 2023
                                • 501
                                • New York, Not the city
                                • Send PM

                                #16
                                Originally posted by Rubicon99
                                The T34 is the one tank HL makes that does not need bearing supports so none have been made except the "one offs" by individuals here and there. Its just a tank that can operate very very well with a loose tolerance and sloppy tracks.

                                Sounds like the Real Russian T-34.

                                Comment

                                • keilau
                                  Senior Member

                                  • Mar 2021
                                  • 1815
                                  • Windy City
                                  • Send PM

                                  #17
                                  Originally posted by hblake1427
                                  Adding on to this thread, does anyone have a source for a T-34 bearing set? I've looked all over and can't find any.

                                  I see the 8x12x3.5 bearings mentioned above, anyone have experience with that size in a T-34 hull?
                                  The T34-85 tank has a small chassis and no room for external axle cover. You can see the drive gears inside the sidewall of the chassis (in the full scale tank). The 1:16 scale HL T34 uses a short 49 mm drive shaft. However, if you get a ball bearing gearbox, you will have 2 ball bearings for each side of the short drive axle.
                                  Click image for larger version  Name:	T34Scale.jpg Views:	1 Size:	100.8 KB ID:	373725Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_5096.jpg Views:	1 Size:	173.4 KB ID:	373726

                                  Comment

                                  • hblake1427
                                    Member
                                    • Aug 2022
                                    • 13
                                    • Send PM

                                    #18
                                    Ah, I figured the shorter axle would make a bearing a little difficult.

                                    The reason I'm asking is that after upgrading to metal sprockets and a steel gearbox, the left sprocket tends to be... squeaky. Only when the treads are running with weight on them.
                                    Pick up the T-34 and run the tracks, no squeak.

                                    At first I thought is was an interaction between the sprocket and hull of the tank, but after wrapping the outer wall of the sprocket and electrical tape, it still squeaks.

                                    I won't have time for a full teardown until the weekend, but my next guess would be a gearbox component.

                                    Thanks all for the wisdom, in any case.

                                    Comment

                                    • Rubicon99
                                      Senior Member

                                      • Dec 2019
                                      • 3311
                                      • Send PM

                                      #19
                                      Originally posted by hblake1427
                                      Ah, I figured the shorter axle would make a bearing a little difficult.

                                      The reason I'm asking is that after upgrading to metal sprockets and a steel gearbox, the left sprocket tends to be... squeaky. Only when the treads are running with weight on them.
                                      Pick up the T-34 and run the tracks, no squeak.

                                      At first I thought is was an interaction between the sprocket and hull of the tank, but after wrapping the outer wall of the sprocket and electrical tape, it still squeaks.

                                      I won't have time for a full teardown until the weekend, but my next guess would be a gearbox component.

                                      Thanks all for the wisdom, in any case.
                                      Squeaky and clacking is absolutely normal for the T34. The real one has the same problem. The squeaky has to do with the way the metal sprocket teeth (more like circles) and metal track guide teeth interact under tension. Lifting the tank off the ground removes the tension.

                                      The squeaking will never go away, it only gets worse, but that is what makes the T34 a T34 it distinctive track noises.

                                      A metal track and sprocket T34 is simply a noisy tank and nothing can change that. If you want it to be quite then you have to run the plastic track and sprocket combination.

                                      Comment

                                      • hblake1427
                                        Member
                                        • Aug 2022
                                        • 13
                                        • Send PM

                                        #20
                                        I see. My first thought when the squeaking started was "wow that sounds just like a T-34 in the movies"

                                        The only weird thing is that the squeaking is just on one side and the tank has plastic tracks, but I can learn to love it.

                                        Comment

                                        Working...