how to tell if your esc is blown?

Collapse
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • dragons_rc
    Member

    • Jun 2021
    • 5
    • Send PM

    #1

    how to tell if your esc is blown?

    i think my esc is dead after i had a sparky mishap while plugging in my 6s lipo the esc will not make any sounds also my beastx wont power up but the RX does... thoughts?
  • xviper
    Hobby Squawk Regular

    • Jan 2014
    • 8753
    • Calgary, Canada
    • Send PM

    #2
    Plug in a known good motor to the suspect ESC or plug in a good known ESC to the existing motor. A "sparky mishap" when plugging in a battery means (to me) that you reversed the polarity and this generally will blow the ESC. It's also usually accompanied by smoke and sometimes, flames.
    BTW, an ESC doesn't make any noise. It's the motor that makes the sounds when you plug a battery in.

    Comment

    • dragons_rc
      Member

      • Jun 2021
      • 5
      • Send PM

      #3
      Originally posted by xviper
      Plug in a known good motor to the suspect ESC or plug in a good known ESC to the existing motor. A "sparky mishap" when plugging in a battery means (to me) that you reversed the polarity and this generally will blow the ESC. It's also usually accompanied by smoke and sometimes, flames.
      BTW, an ESC doesn't make any noise. It's the motor that makes the sounds when you plug a battery in.
      yeah i had a light crash while hovering didnt see any damage but i guess 2 wires got nicked by debris and when i went to plug battery in later that day sparky happened fused the 2 wires together now nothing... is there a way to bench test a motor without an esc?

      Comment

      • xviper
        Hobby Squawk Regular

        • Jan 2014
        • 8753
        • Calgary, Canada
        • Send PM

        #4
        Originally posted by dragons_rc

        yeah i had a light crash while hovering didnt see any damage but i guess 2 wires got nicked by debris and when i went to plug battery in later that day sparky happened fused the 2 wires together now nothing... is there a way to bench test a motor without an esc?
        Not a safe way to do it, an ESC is necessary to run the motor. If you have another plane, you could easily access the wires behind that motor and plug in the one from the "crashed" plane. Or take the motor out of another plane and plug it into the "bad" ESC. Just make sure you use the same number of cells for the battery that is meant for that motor or ESC. IE, don't use a 6s battery on a motor that normally runs on 3s. You can always use a smaller (# of cells) battery for testing.
        Shorting out the power leads likely burns out the ESC. Probably the motor is still good but not guaranteed.

        Comment

        • dragons_rc
          Member

          • Jun 2021
          • 5
          • Send PM

          #5
          this is on a trex 470 heli and unfortunately its the only one i have

          Comment

          • xviper
            Hobby Squawk Regular

            • Jan 2014
            • 8753
            • Calgary, Canada
            • Send PM

            #6
            Maybe you fly at a place where someone else there could loan you a spare motor or ESC. If not, take it to a hobby shop and ask them to throw on a spare motor. People in the hobby usually have these things just laying around. I've got a box full of them. You don't even need the same motor/ESC nor do you need to load it up. Just hook it up long enough to see if it turns.

            Comment

            • dragons_rc
              Member

              • Jun 2021
              • 5
              • Send PM

              #7
              ok ill see if i can

              Comment

              • MeyerVW
                crash test pilot

                • May 2020
                • 280
                • Dude who likes flying.
                • Send PM

                #8
                Check all the connections between the motor and esc. Especially the soldier ends. I had an issue once and it turned out to be a loose soldier joint on the esc. The wires are solid and if moved a bunch can break connection. Brand new esc and I had never flown it.
                When this happened I had a lot of the same issues you describe.

                Comment

                • dragons_rc
                  Member

                  • Jun 2021
                  • 5
                  • Send PM

                  #9
                  ill check all the solder joints ty i didnt even think of that

                  Comment

                  • radfordc

                    • Jul 2017
                    • 375
                    • Lansing, KS
                    • Send PM

                    #10
                    How do you tell if your ESC is blown? If it looks similar to this....it's blown! Click image for larger version

Name:	ESC blown.jpg
Views:	1102
Size:	105.9 KB
ID:	315876

                    Comment

                    Working...