Roban - World Class Scale Helicopters

Preferred metal track for 1/16 scale modern MBT

Collapse
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • keilau
    Senior Member

    • Mar 2021
    • 1833
    • Windy City
    • Send PM

    #1

    Preferred metal track for 1/16 scale modern MBT

    Originally posted by built-for-u
    Hello,

    Sorry for the late reply, we are on vacation now.

    This is a double pins track, and the pins are completely closed, the material is (aluminum) alloy.

    Sincerely,​
    Discover ToucanHobby's collection of high-quality remote controlled hydraulic engineering vehicles, tractor trucks, tank replicas, cars, and ship models. Enjoy our detailed, meticulously crafted models suitable for enthusiasts and collectors alike.


    My favorite metal track for modern MBT is the Tamiya hybrid original track, cheap and readily available. I saw this new track from Can Shou which sounds very appealing. I will be ordering one to see its quality. But I do not drive my tank really hard. It would be wonderful to see a review of this track by the hard driving tankers.

    Bless NATO, they make the track standard for Abrams, Challenger2 and Leo2A6.
    Click image for larger version

Name:	image.png
Views:	238
Size:	359.5 KB
ID:	401541
  • Rubicon99
    Senior Member

    • Dec 2019
    • 3314
    • Send PM

    #2
    Originally posted by keilau
    Discover ToucanHobby's collection of high-quality remote controlled hydraulic engineering vehicles, tractor trucks, tank replicas, cars, and ship models. Enjoy our detailed, meticulously crafted models suitable for enthusiasts and collectors alike.


    My favorite metal track for modern MBT is the Tamiya hybrid original track, cheap and readily available. I saw this new track from Can Shou which sounds very appealing. I will be ordering one to see its quality. But I do not drive my tank really hard. It would be wonderful to see a review of this track by the hard driving tankers.

    Bless NATO, they make the track standard for Abrams, Challenger2 and Leo2A6.
    It's is sold under a few other names. DKLM and Toucan sell this track under their names. I have several sets of it and have run it very very hard. It is good tough track overall. It has a few issues that may or may not be a problem for some people.

    This first issue is the track guide teeth are a little short in height and as such do not hold as well against the sprocket track retaining rings as they could like taller like the Tamiya guides. So detracting at the sprockets can be more common then with Tamiya tracks.

    The second issue is the rubber used on the pads. It is soft and has a high coefficient of friction when used on hard packed surfaces or concrete/asphalt. It grips so well it actually can cause the tracks to pull off the idler and road wheels in a turn on the above surfaces. Tamiya uses a harder rubber compound and this greatly reduces the coefficient of friction so the "pulling off" issue is not a big of problem.

    Lastly the track is heavy and needs to be used with at least 390 motor upgrades if you want to turn with any authority.

    I have largely pulled this type of tracks "out of service" as the Tamiya tracks are functionally superior in every aspect.

    Comment

    • keilau
      Senior Member

      • Mar 2021
      • 1833
      • Windy City
      • Send PM

      #3
      Originally posted by Rubicon99

      It's is sold under a few other names. DKLM and Toucan sell this track under their names. I have several sets of it and have run it very very hard. It is good tough track overall. It has a few issues that may or may not be a problem for some people.

      This first issue is the track guide teeth are a little short in height and as such do not hold as well against the sprocket track retaining rings as they could like taller like the Tamiya guides. So detracting at the sprockets can be more common then with Tamiya tracks.

      The second issue is the rubber used on the pads. It is soft and has a high coefficient of friction when used on hard packed surfaces or concrete/asphalt. It grips so well it actually can cause the tracks to pull off the idler and road wheels in a turn on the above surfaces. Tamiya uses a harder rubber compound and this greatly reduces the coefficient of friction so the "pulling off" issue is not a big of problem.

      Lastly the track is heavy and needs to be used with at least 390 motor upgrades if you want to turn with any authority.

      I have largely pulled this type of tracks "out of service" as the Tamiya tracks are functionally superior in every aspect.
      Rubicon99 , thank you for taking the time to write this long review on the track. Judging from the $400+ price of the Tamiya metal track, I am not sure how much longer the Tamiya original hybrid track will continue to be available at the current under $100 price.

      I have 2 Tamiya original hybrid tracks for the Leo2 and Challenger2. I am looking for a 3rd pair for the TD M60 track upgrade. Are you interested in selling any of your "pulled out of service" tracks?

      Comment

      • Rubicon99
        Senior Member

        • Dec 2019
        • 3314
        • Send PM

        #4
        Originally posted by keilau
        Rubicon99 , thank you for taking the time to write this long review on the track. Judging from the $400+ price of the Tamiya metal track, I am not sure how much longer the Tamiya original hybrid track will continue to be available at the current under $100 price.

        I have 2 Tamiya original hybrid tracks for the Leo2 and Challenger2. I am looking for a 3rd pair for the TD M60 track upgrade. Are you interested in selling any of your "pulled out of service" tracks?
        I have stocked up on Tamiya Leopard 2 and Abrams tracks having grabbed some crazy deals on both recently from people selling off Tamiya "take off" tracks cheap. I have two relatively new sets of both types on top of the prior spares bought a year ago.

        Even still my "out of service" tracks are heavily worn and look it and I am not comfortable selling them in their current condition. They are really only useful as cosmetic accessory parts for mounting on hulls and turrets as "spare" links.

        Comment

        • keilau
          Senior Member

          • Mar 2021
          • 1833
          • Windy City
          • Send PM

          #5
          Originally posted by Rubicon99

          I have stocked up on Tamiya Leopard 2 and Abrams tracks having grabbed some crazy deals on both recently from people selling off Tamiya "take off" tracks cheap. I have two relatively new sets of both types on top of the prior spares bought a year ago.

          Even still my "out of service" tracks are heavily worn and look it and I am not comfortable selling them in their current condition. They are really only useful as cosmetic accessory parts for mounting on hulls and turrets as "spare" links.
          Fully understand. I can still get the RC original track from Tamiya US Store, but quite a bit more than from AAF store.

          I may give the Can Shou track a try. Just that I am always a sucker for trying something different and the lower price is a nice bonus.

          Comment

          • Handy Lance
            Member
            • Mar 2024
            • 117
            • Near a river PNW, next to a few tracks
            • Send PM

            #6
            Originally posted by keilau
            Fully understand. I can still get the RC original track from Tamiya US Store, but quite a bit more than from AAF store.

            I may give the Can Shou track a try. Just that I am always a sucker for trying something different and the lower price is a nice bonus.
            This link is for Abrams Tamiya metal tracks for 133$ that seems like a good deal?
            There is no pic. I’m thinking of getting a set.

            Comment

            • keilau
              Senior Member

              • Mar 2021
              • 1833
              • Windy City
              • Send PM

              #7
              Originally posted by Handy Lance

              This link is for Abrams Tamiya metal tracks for 133$ that seems like a good deal?
              There is no pic. I’m thinking of getting a set.
              Yes, it is a reasonalably priced Tamiya track. I have not been able to find better price recenly. Some ebay sellers want much higher price.

              For many years, I was able to get the tracks from AAF Tank Museum PX for well under $100, but AAF closed earlier last year.

              Comment

              • Rubicon99
                Senior Member

                • Dec 2019
                • 3314
                • Send PM

                #8
                Originally posted by Handy Lance

                This link is for Abrams Tamiya metal tracks for 133$ that seems like a good deal?
                There is no pic. I’m thinking of getting a set.
                It's $133 per side so $266 for a complete set.

                Comment

                • keilau
                  Senior Member

                  • Mar 2021
                  • 1833
                  • Windy City
                  • Send PM

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Rubicon99

                  It's $133 per side so $266 for a complete set.
                  Originally posted by tamiyausstore
                  ITEM# 8080384 RC TRACKS ASSY: 56041/36212

                  MSRP: $133.00
                  The description is in plural. But it may mean nothing. I will not order until getting a clarification from Tamiya US Store.​ The upgrade metal part listing seems a little more explicit. Again, ask before ordering.
                  Please prove that you are Human before accessing this website

                  Comment

                  • Rubicon99
                    Senior Member

                    • Dec 2019
                    • 3314
                    • Send PM

                    #10
                    Originally posted by keilau

                    The description is in plural. But it may mean nothing. I will not order until getting a clarification from Tamiya US Store.​
                    I found out the hard way with the Abrams tracks. That's why I always tell people it is an expensive option and direct them towards Leopard 2 tracks which used to be sold as a set for around $100.

                    Comment

                    • Handy Lance
                      Member
                      • Mar 2024
                      • 117
                      • Near a river PNW, next to a few tracks
                      • Send PM

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Rubicon99

                      It's $133 per side so $266 for a complete set.
                      I believe you

                      I have Tamiya cars

                      Comment

                      • sclui56
                        Member

                        • Mar 2021
                        • 415
                        • LAX
                        • Send PM

                        #12
                        I inquired about these at Tamiya back in 2021 and this is what I was told, hence I went ahead and bought the Leo ones from AAF per Rubicon's suggestion:

                        Click image for larger version

Name:	image.png
Views:	162
Size:	41.9 KB
ID:	401638

                        Comment

                        • keilau
                          Senior Member

                          • Mar 2021
                          • 1833
                          • Windy City
                          • Send PM

                          #13
                          Originally posted by sclui56
                          I inquired about these at Tamiya back in 2021 and this is what I was told, hence I went ahead and bought the Leo ones from AAF per Rubicon's suggestion:

                          Click image for larger version  Name:	image.png Views:	8 Size:	41.9 KB ID:	401638
                          I missed the AAF Tank Museum PX Shop. The ladies there, Natasha and Karen, were friendly, helpful and knowledgeable too. In the early 2000, the Danville, VA RC tank battle ground was the biggest on this side of Atlanta. Lacking a reasonable price source, it is unlikely for me to acquire more Tamiya tracks. The $80 Metal Tracks W/ Fixed Rubber​ is my low cost option.

                          Originally posted by Rubicon99
                          It's is sold under a few other names. DKLM and Toucan sell this track under their names. I have several sets of it and have run it very very hard. It is good tough track overall. It has a few issues that may or may not be a problem for some people.

                          This first issue is the track guide teeth are a little short in height and as such do not hold as well against the sprocket track retaining rings as they could like taller like the Tamiya guides. So detracting at the sprockets can be more common then with Tamiya tracks.

                          The second issue is the rubber used on the pads. It is soft and has a high coefficient of friction when used on hard packed surfaces or concrete/asphalt. It grips so well it actually can cause the tracks to pull off the idler and road wheels in a turn on the above surfaces. Tamiya uses a harder rubber compound and this greatly reduces the coefficient of friction so the "pulling off" issue is not a big of problem.

                          Lastly the track is heavy and needs to be used with at least 390 motor upgrades if you want to turn with any authority.

                          I have largely pulled this type of tracks "out of service" as the Tamiya tracks are functionally superior in every aspect.

                          Comment

                          • keilau
                            Senior Member

                            • Mar 2021
                            • 1833
                            • Windy City
                            • Send PM

                            #14
                            After a 2 years debate, I finally decided on the Heng Long Challenger 2 for my first UK RC tank model. It is a post cold war era MBT so I expected the metal upgrades to be similar to the Leopard and Abrams. The upgrades include ball bearing steel gearbox, sprocket and idealer wheel, metal tracks, drive motor shaft bearing, stronger suspension coil spring plus a high capacity lithium ion battery and 2.5" speaker. All pretty routine items.
                            Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_0071.jpg Views:	0 Size:	90.8 KB ID:	452729 Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_0072.jpg Views:	0 Size:	132.2 KB ID:	452728 Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_0073.jpg Views:	0 Size:	111.1 KB ID:	452726 Click image for larger version  Name:	metalsprocket.jpg Views:	0 Size:	73.6 KB ID:	452723
                            My favorite gearbox is the Heng Xin with 390 motor. To my disappointment, The Heng Xin gearbox cannot be mounted with 390 motors because the Challenger2 chassis is 0.5 inch narrower than the Leo and Abrams. I use the Taigen/Torro black 380 for now.

                            I found a paired Tamiya track set package at ttpmodels.com in England. The shipping is cheap and quite fast.
                            Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_0065.jpg Views:	0 Size:	79.5 KB ID:	452727 Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_0066.jpg Views:	0 Size:	125.7 KB ID:	452725 Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_0074.jpg Views:	0 Size:	116.3 KB ID:	452724 Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_0077.jpg Views:	0 Size:	137.4 KB ID:	452730

                            Comment

                            • cleong
                              Member

                              • Feb 2024
                              • 34
                              • Send PM

                              #15
                              I run Tamiya Leopard 2 tracks on my Heng Long Challenger 2 but I was advised to get sprockets that were designed to be compatible with Tamiya tracks, which was what I did.

                              Comment

                              • keilau
                                Senior Member

                                • Mar 2021
                                • 1833
                                • Windy City
                                • Send PM

                                #16
                                Originally posted by cleong
                                I run Tamiya Leopard 2 tracks on my Heng Long Challenger 2 but I was advised to get sprockets that were designed to be compatible with Tamiya tracks, which was what I did.
                                Tamiya is the grand daddy of 1/16 scale RC tank. Heng Long, Mato, Taigen/Torro are all careful in following the Tamiya scale. I have 3 sets of Tamiya tracks and they all fit perfectly on Heng Long tanks. Some with Mato sprocket.

                                The only exception is the Tongde brand. Their track width and pitch are both off. To use the Tamiya tracks on my TD M60A1, I have to change to the HL dual current drive system and use the HL Abrams sprocket. I learnt this from Rubicon99 . It works, but it is the main reason I stopped buying Tongde. Tongde use very soft metal on their case of the TD steel gearbox resulted in unsecured mounting and added to the switching to HL dual current drive system decision.

                                Comment

                                • tank_me
                                  Senior Member

                                  • Feb 2022
                                  • 1186
                                  • Send PM

                                  #17
                                  Originally posted by keilau

                                  Tamiya is the grand daddy of 1/16 scale RC tank. Heng Long, Mato, Taigen/Torro are all careful in following the Tamiya scale. I have 3 sets of Tamiya tracks and they all fit perfectly on Heng Long tanks. Some with Mato sprocket.

                                  The only exception is the Tongde brand. Their track width and pitch are both off. To use the Tamiya tracks on my TD M60A1, I have to change to the HL dual current drive system and use the HL Abrams sprocket. I learnt this from Rubicon99 . It works, but it is the main reason I stopped buying Tongde. Tongde use very soft metal on their case of the TD steel gearbox resulted in unsecured mounting and added to the switching to HL dual current drive system decision.
                                  While I do like the dual diff gearboxes and use them in like 6 of my tanks, the M60A2 I finally have battling has battled on the regular metal Tongde gearboxes just fine. I did create some braces that wedge between the gearboxes enclosures that doesn't allow them to move in toward the centerline of the tank. They are just sheet plastic "mistakes" from my 3D printer made out of ASA and glued together. Each one is just friction fit and easily removed for maintenance. It takes all the stress off of those side mounting screws.

                                  Click image for larger version

Name:	Screenshot 2026-09-19 230051.png
Views:	0
Size:	1.64 MB
ID:	452786

                                  Comment

                                  Working...