Ok, you talked me into it. I have the HobbyKing C-47 up next on the bench, I'll be painting invasion stripes on it and I've already got the "That's All Brother" decals from Callie. Once this is done and flown I'm ordering the He111.
I really want to fly the C-47 on the D-DAY anniversary June 6th.
I have the Graupner He-111, which is basically the same model, but an earlier version. Alpha has asked m to make a post on my observations and experiences with my Graupner 111, and I'm happy to do so.
First off, I love my 111. It is a rock-solid model and the detailing is beautiful. Here's how I've outfitted my 111:
Power Train:
Motors: Turnigy Aerodrive 4240-740Kv motors (note: I did have to cut out the webbing on the front of the nacelles (between the motor and spinner) because this 4240 was a little too long and was would've rubbed against the fiberglass webbing).
Props: MAS 11x7, counter rotating
Spinner: Dubro 2.5" (maybe 2.75", I don't remember for sure) 3-bladed spinner. Note (as you can see in the photos): the spinner are a little too small (diameter) and the shape is too pointy.
Servos:
Aileron and Flaps: HS-81
Rudder and Elevator: Futaba S3010
I see that Motion recommends HS-D645 servos. I fly these servos on my 90" Phoenix A-26 and am very happy with them. My feeling is that they are a really good choice for this model.
Gear: I believe that the servos are Futaba S3010s, but it's immaterial as the BH version will come with servoless retracts. My servo-actuated retracts work just fine (but I did have to plug them into different channels in the RX so that I could subtrim them to retract and deploy properly.
Radio System: Admiral 10-channel RX and Spek DX9. This plane can be flown with a 6-channel radio (well, the new version with servoless retracts), but I recommend a 9 channel. Each Aileron has its own channel. I have set up my motor for differential thrust (so, each throttle needs its own channel). For the case of my servo-actuated retracts, each retract servo has its own channel, so that the retract movement can be properly set. Obviously, mixing is required to run this type of setup.
Differential Throttle: I do this on almost all of my multi-engine planes. It helps a lot with taxiing. I do not fly with differential thrust though.
Battery: Admiral Pro and HRB 4S-5000. The 5AH battery is a tight fit, but it will fit.
Construction:
The balsa and ply construction is very solid and the RX compartment is plenty roomy. The skin is printed with panel lines and looks awesome.
Field Assembly:
As a rule, i do not like to assemble planes at the field, if I can avoid it. I have a trailer that I use to transport my 1.6m+ planes to the field. My Graupner 111 is a real hassle to assemble at the field. Honestly, I probably would not fly it as much, if I had to assemble it at the field. With almost everything having it's own RX channel, getting it hooked up properly is a logistical nightmare. So, I only remove the wings for depot maintenance.
Handling Characteristics:
Ground:
I fly on a grass field. I have no problem taxiing on the grass. To the best of my knowledge, I have never nosed her over, even on landing.
Takeoff:
I've found her easy to take off. The maiden was pretty bad, but since then, she's been a peach to get airborne. Typical tail-dragger technique: Get moving, allow the tail to come up, ease the throttle forward, then gentle back pressure on the elevator, for a gentle ease into air.
Flight:
This is probably my only not-overwhelmingly-positive remark on my Graupner 111. It took me about 5 flights to figure out how she wanted to be flown. The CG was fine, but she really wanted to drag her tail in the turns, almost to the point that I was getting worried that she was about to stall. If I bank-n-yanked her, like a fighter, she did fine. With moderate rudder and aileron, she wanted to drag her tail and increase her bank angle. There is noticeable dihedral in the wings. So, seemingly coordinated turns were causing too much bank. I have since learned that the best bomber-like bank turns, I give her a ton of rudder and cross-control with the ailerons to keep the bank angle reasonable. She doesn't drag her tail in these types of turns.
With this power train, my 111 has power to spare. I usually cruise at about 1/2 throttle. When I pour on the coals, she really books. I have pretty high throws; so, she has plenty of roll and pitch authority. Rolls are easy (not fast, but easy) and loops and Immelmanns are easy, too, when I get tired of flying her like a scale bomber. In fact, when I want to fly her like a fighter, she reminds me quite a bit of how my FlightLine P-38 handles. Not fast rolls. Not crazy tight loops. But, nice solid rolls and loops.
Flight time: On a 4S-5AH battery, flying mixed throttle, I get an easy 5 minutes of flight time and usually land with 3.7 - 3.8 v/cell.
What could be better? Maybe a retractable tail wheel on a plane this size. Servoless, suspension gear (which will come in the BH version that Motion carries). It'd have been nice to have a 3-blade spinner in the correct shape. I just hate seeing two-bladed props on 3 or 4 bladed warbirds.
if you're on the fence about getting this plane, my recommendation is to go for it. It's a beautifully crafted warbird.
Here's a video of my second flight, warts and all. As you can see in the video, she was still dragging her tail through some of the turns and I hadn't gotten my throws set where I wanted them.
Alpha, the only thing that bothers me are the main gear struts. The he-111 had struts more like a Mosquito, Lancaster or DC-3. After market struts are hard to find
Agreed. The landing gear on the original plane aren't anything like what we're using on RC planes today. Would be a serious mod to get them to look anything like the original.
Thanks for posting your experience with the He-111, Oxotnik! I really appreciate it! One clarification for readers though is that per the Motion RC product page, the Black Horse He-111 does not include servoless retracts. They're cited in the Required section. What IS included in the box is the landing gear strut itself:
Yes they are , all the markings / lines etc are printed on the covering …. nothing stopping u from say going with a winter scheme and spraying white randomly over the plane
or even doing a full respray and the vinyl covering takes to paint really well.
I ended up putting strips on the wing and tail as I saw a photo of one with it..
I'm currently building this BH He-111 bought in Eur 2 months ago, (before MotionRC started carrying the BH line). I love unusual subject warbirds and BH does a good job with their ARF's. And now they're available in the USA....Kudos to MotionRC! Hope you will be carrying spares because I also have the BH Fieseler Storch built 3 years ago, also obtained in Eur.
Here are some pictures for those thinking about this model...caution: may persuade you. :)
On my dining room table being built
A good view of the interior fuse area, battery compartment to the left, 4S's fit well. Note the wing attachment screws on either side of the rudder servo in middle. Clean layout but we'll see how tight it gets when I add the radio gear, efuel gauge, etc.
Wing servo wells are well done with short linkages.
I'm building the electric version with Cobra 3515-14, 950kv motors and CC talon 60 esc's. Glass cowling
These are the stock oleo struts and wheels. 5mm pin for mounting stock bracket. I opted for servoless retracts with metal trunion and 136mm offset oleo struts from HK. Retracts fit with just a bit of adjustment. The servo pocket is for throttle if using nitro/gas. Gas tanks are in the wings.
Cockpit area comes with the following already completed and includes this pilot figure- not too crazy about him.
The nose of the aircraft...if this doesn't convince you nothing will.
General comments on my build so far:
1. Components are laid out well in the box and very safely packed. A plus.
2. Instruction manual is fairly concise and if you have some previous ARF building under your belt no issue.
3. Supplied parts are easily replaced if you want, nothing exotic. I'm using stock parts except in a few areas where my preferences dictate otherwise.
4. Well thought out layout cries for electric version. Looking at the gas/nitro parts it's more involved and not worth my time for the sound benefit.
5. Only issue i've encountered thus far is the wing joining. My left wing is tight snuggling up to the fuse and I'm trying to figure out the best solution. Right wing no problem.
A great and unusual model and looking forward to flying it!
My HE-111 arrived today - one day early! I am very impressed with the plane so far. It appears to be very well built. All the parts are there and I can't wait to start this build.
My thanks to MotionRc, Alpha and Stuart! I hope you guys are already working on my future order of a couple of G4M Bettys!:)
Luckily, since I’m going to be the first person to hit the buy-your-very-own-Do-335-now button, I’ll be assured of getting one before they sell out. I b smart that way... :)
Ordered mine on Saturday evening.....surfing buzzed which is always dangerous....saw 6 left in the count on Motion's page, and next thing I knew , my right index finger had "One Clicked" it on PayPal.....
It arrived Thursday lunchtime. Looks like they'd sold out by Tuesday morning. Good timing!!
The box is in perfect condition....haven't unboxed it yet, but all looks good....packed exactly like the Phoenix A26. Another Vietnamese, built up balsa model.....a very nice one
Comment