Official Freewing F/A-18C Hornet 90mm EDF Thread

Collapse
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Hugh Wiedman
    replied
    Originally posted by Dr8820
    I have a question; I purchased a Blue Angels version in early 2025 and I’m assuming the elevators had 17g servos then they were out of stock…I purchased 7 more right before Christmas 2025 when they were back in stock and they had 23g servos..how can I tell if the older model were changed?
    You'll need to remove the servo to see the servo model number on the side, then match that number in the parts section for its description

    Leave a comment:


  • Dr8820
    replied
    I have a question; I purchased a Blue Angels version in early 2025 and I’m assuming the elevators had 17g servos then they were out of stock…I purchased 7 more right before Christmas 2025 when they were back in stock and they had 23g servos..how can I tell if the older model were changed?

    Leave a comment:


  • Hugh Wiedman
    replied
    Originally posted by GliderGuy
    Heads up…Similar handles:

    Gliderguider
    vs
    GliderGuy

    Sorry for your loss.

    I went to a higher torque servo on my F-4 as well…along with heavy duty hardware driving the stab.

    - GG
    I installed ProModeler servos in the horizontal stabs on both my F18's. Smooth as butter and on 8S possibly even a better idea.

    Leave a comment:


  • Evan D
    replied
    If you did have 4.9V putting in a choke isn't going to help. Chokes are to reduce AC ripple from your ESC.


    Originally posted by Gliderguider
    My new Freewing F18 V2 just went in at about a 20 degree angle from 200 feet. My telemetry read 4.9 volts which is way to low to move the stab at 20 percent cord going 80 mph. I noticed Motion is installing larger and larger servos on the stab with each new version. That tells me they know about a known problem.I was at the rear of recommended CG. It’s a sad feeling pulling full up an watching a slow increasing dive into the ground. They need to increase the BEC voltage to at least 5.5 volts. Going thru a control box only increases the voltage drop to the servos. I will NEVER go thru that blue control box again!!

    Leave a comment:


  • Dr8820
    replied
    Originally posted by GliderGuy
    Yes…these are deeply discussed on other EDF jet threads.
    A single choke on several wires is fine. Use the largest size the spot has room for. Their effectiveness at reducing frame holds and frame losses are documented in other EDF jet threads.

    I suggest you get a variety pack with lots of sizes. They are cheap and easy to install.

    -GG

    https://a.co/d/0gxOt4Vz
    I have 8 of these Freewing planes, I’ll be getting these and installing them in my planes to lessen the chance of crashing…thanks!

    Leave a comment:


  • GliderGuy
    replied
    Originally posted by Gliderguider
    My new Freewing F18 V2 just went in at about a 20 degree angle from 200 feet. My telemetry read 4.9 volts which is way to low to move the stab at 20 percent cord going 80 mph. I noticed Motion is installing larger and larger servos on the stab with each new version. That tells me they know about a known problem.I was at the rear of recommended CG. It’s a sad feeling pulling full up watching a slow increasing dive into the ground. They need to increase the BEC voltage to at least 5.5 volts. Going thru a control box only increases the voltage drop to the servos. I will NEVER go thru that blue control box again!!
    It’s often a challenge to pin down the cause of a crash. I’ve flown (literally) thousands of EDF flights with blue boxes without issue. I’ve had birds do exactly as you describe BEFORE installing RF chokes but ZERO crashes since I began installing them on my EDF jets.

    Blue box issue? Probably not…
    RF noise causing control issues…maybe more likely!

    -GG

    Leave a comment:


  • GliderGuy
    replied
    Yes…these are deeply discussed on other EDF jet threads.
    A single choke on several wires is fine. Use the largest size the spot has room for. Their effectiveness at reducing frame holds and frame losses are documented in other EDF jet threads.

    I suggest you get a variety pack with lots of sizes. They are cheap and easy to install.

    -GG

    Leave a comment:


  • Fast N Light
    replied
    Originally posted by GliderGuy
    Also…Gliderguider, It never hurts to install RF chokes all around the electronics as a preventative, and light-weight, action.

    Clip-on RF chokes on the battery side/RX side/BEC side of all the wires from the ESC placed as close to the ESC as possible plus as near as possible to servos…especially on long wire runs. Search for RF chokes on Amazon. The output/motor side of the ESC produces less RF noise, so putting chokes between the motor and ESC is not needed. But, you can, if you want to.

    It’s most important for high-current EDF ESCs, but I put them on my new P-51, too.

    -GG
    Are these the devices you are referring to?

    For the motor output wires do you use a single larger chock on all 3 wires to together?

    Click image for larger version

Name:	2026-10-17 08_42_49-Amazon.com_ Windspeed 30P Snap on Ferrite Chokes 0.2IN_5MM RFI EMI Noise Ferrite.jpg
Views:	110
Size:	134.3 KB
ID:	453521

    Leave a comment:


  • GliderGuy
    replied
    Also…Gliderguider, It never hurts to install RF chokes all around the electronics as a preventative, and light-weight, action.

    Clip-on RF chokes on the battery side/RX side/BEC side of all the wires from the ESC placed as close to the ESC as possible plus as near as possible to servos…especially on long wire runs. Search for RF chokes on Amazon. The output/motor side of the ESC produces less RF noise, so putting chokes between the motor and ESC is not needed. But, you can, if you want to.

    It’s most important for high-current EDF ESCs, but I put them on my new P-51, too.

    -GG

    Leave a comment:


  • Elbee
    commented on 's reply
    On me. I will. Thanks.

  • Airguardian
    replied
    I've been using separate Rx power supply for years to avoid these sort of things... but recently I've been giving in to stock BEC setups because many models come out too nose heavy otherwise. :(

    Leave a comment:


  • GliderGuy
    replied
    Heads up…Similar handles:

    Gliderguider
    vs
    GliderGuy

    Sorry for your loss.

    I went to a higher torque servo on my F-4 as well…along with heavy duty hardware driving the stab.

    - GG

    Leave a comment:


  • Elbee
    replied
    GliderGuy,

    Terrible loss and seemingly avoidable.

    I've often thought to go back to the days of onboard RX battery packs.

    I will certainly do that with my F-18 now.

    Best, LB

    Leave a comment:


  • Gliderguider
    replied
    My new Freewing F18 V2 just went in at about a 20 degree angle from 200 feet. My telemetry read 4.9 volts which is way to low to move the stab at 20 percent cord going 80 mph. I noticed Motion is installing larger and larger servos on the stab with each new version. That tells me they know about a known problem.I was at the rear of recommended CG. It’s a sad feeling pulling full up an watching a slow increasing dive into the ground. They need to increase the BEC voltage to at least 5.5 volts. Going thru a control box only increases the voltage drop to the servos. I will NEVER go thru that blue control box again!!

    Leave a comment:


  • Airguardian
    replied
    I can imagine the difficulty. With the aggravating factor of being INSIDE the plane. Not just the risk, but the nasty Gs.

    Certainly not a fun position to be in.

    Leave a comment:


  • jetpltrich
    replied
    Originally posted by Airguardian
    Great pics Hugh!
    I'm also in for the larger (Super)hornet! :D
    I will be as well.

    I asked AI about my classmate who Faught an F-18 back to shore after FCC cat launch during CQ events and this is what I got. The pilot was a classmate of mine in initial training at Southwest Airlines, and he was a hero by me and others but very humble about the event. He was a super great guy and sadly he passed away from cancer a few years before I retired.

    In the early Lot F-18A, if you lost both 1553 MUX channels or had dual FCC fails after launch, you went to DEL - Direct Electric Link. No augmentation, no auto-trim, no yaw damper. The jet becomes very sensitive in pitch, and in roll it feels like it's hunting because the aileron and differential stab aren't scheduled together anymore.

    At low altitude right after a cat shot - you're heavy, around 250-270 knots climbing out - that's the worst place to get it. You have to hand-fly pitch attitude with the stick force feeling all wrong and keep the beta under control with rudder because the yaw CAS is gone.

    Guys who went through it described it as "balancing on a basketball." You can do it, but it's full-time work, and any PIO will overstress the airframe. The fact he got it to a field and landed out of it clean - no runway overrun, no ejection - means he never let it diverge.

    That's why people remember it. It wasn't a flameout where you just glide - you had to actively fly a broken jet for 15-20 minutes.
    No wonder your Southwest classmates still talk about it.

    Even if the paperwork is buried in a 1984 HAZREP filing cabinet at Oceana, the story fits perfectly.

    Early Lot F-18A, cat launch off Indy during CQ off Virginia Capes, FCC/DFCS drops to DEL / degraded right after rotation, pilot has to hand-fly it with no dampers, bingo's to a Cecil/Oceana shore field and saves the jet.

    For 1984 that was a big deal - they were still writing the book on that airplane. The fleet fix later improved the FCC fail-op logic, but at that time saving one in that mode was a legitimate save.

    Richard.

    Leave a comment:


  • Airguardian
    replied
    Great pics Hugh!
    I'm also in for the larger (Super)hornet! :D

    Leave a comment:


  • xviper
    replied
    Originally posted by Hugh Wiedman

    Mark me down for that Bad Boy! 😁
    Hehe, they'll sell 3 of them just to our small flying bunch.

    Leave a comment:


  • Hugh Wiedman
    replied
    Originally posted by xviper
    Rumour has it that a 12S, 110mm F-18 could appear in the New Year.
    Mark me down for that Bad Boy! 😁

    Leave a comment:


  • xviper
    replied
    Rumour has it that a 12S, 110mm F-18 could appear in the New Year.

    Leave a comment:

Working...