Official FlightLine 1600mm P-51D Mustang Thread

Collapse
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • GliderGuy
    replied
    I also agree with Hugh and Davegee. Your choice, but the Flightline 1600 mm P-51D is one sweet and well designed bird.

    -GG

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by Hugh Wiedman

    My Opinion, go with the FL 1600mm, out of the box much much better. To get the 1700 "so called dialed in", I spent about $200 bucks (more as the custom Xoar props were extremely expensive) on a new motor (Power 60), and custom made and painted Xoar 2 and 3 blade props along with 4" spinners for 2 and 3 blade props. Now performs great, but still a heavy mother (ah la "My 600 lb Life" TV personality)! If I didn't have extra parts, several extra metal main gear retracts (only sold by FMS early on) and other things, I'd have never spent any time on it. Stock outta da box it's impressive to see on the ground but a real dog to fly. Not so with the 1600, a beautiful bird, a class way above FMS and powered perfectly even with the scale 4 blade prop. Just my humble opinion.

    Not to stink up this thread, but if you want to see photos and a flight video of the repowered 1700, go to my you tube video.
    I agree with Hugh. Years ago I had the FMS 1700 Corsair, P-51D, and P-47D aircraft. Flew the crap out of them! Whereas Hugh had the nice thick air of Miami, I flew out of the Denver area at about 6,000 feet MSL. Hugh said the FMS was a dog compared to the new Flightline P-51D. And for me at 6,000 feet, it was especially so. Still, I enjoyed flying them, the last survivor, the Corsair, was sold to a friend where he has it hanging on display for the past several years.

    I didn't do any of the mods to the planes that Hugh has done, and he is a master of improving flight performance of all these foam airplanes. I'd take his opinion to the bank on this one.

    I am loving the Flightline 1600mm P-51D and have been busy with some modifications of my own with ordnance dropping and a new paint scheme, printed pilot, etc. I'm still at 5,000 feet now so the air is pretty thin like before for me, but I don't think I would trade my Flightline Mustang for the FMS plane now. I'm all about scale performance, and I try to fly all my planes in a scale manner, so the performance on the Flightline 1.6M Mustang is just fine for me.

    But that's your decision, of course. Good luck with whatever you end up doing. Have Fun!!

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • Hugh Wiedman
    replied
    Originally posted by Grate

    is the 1600mm really that much night-and-day better out of the box, or does the FMS 1700 still hold its own once dialed in?
    My Opinion, go with the FL 1600mm, out of the box much much better. To get the 1700 "so called dialed in", I spent about $200 bucks (more as the custom Xoar props were extremely expensive) on a new motor (Power 60), and custom made and painted Xoar 2 and 3 blade props along with 4" spinners for 2 and 3 blade props. Now performs great, but still a heavy mother (ah la "My 600 lb Life" TV personality)! If I didn't have extra parts, several extra metal main gear retracts (only sold by FMS early on) and other things, I'd have never spent any time on it. Stock outta da box it's impressive to see on the ground but a real dog to fly. Not so with the 1600, a beautiful bird, a class way above FMS and powered perfectly even with the scale 4 blade prop. Just my humble opinion.

    Not to stink up this thread, but if you want to see photos and a flight video of the repowered 1700, go to my you tube video.

    Leave a comment:


  • Elbee
    replied
    Grate,

    Welcome to Hobby Squawk, glad to have onboard.

    Best, LB

    Leave a comment:


  • Grate
    replied
    Originally posted by nickwildman81

    So the final question is... am I always going to be comparing the 1700 with the 1600, and be disappointed even after installing a more powerful motor? Should I sell the 1700 in its entirety, with spare parts, and just buy another 1600 instead?
    happymod
    I don't want to put in multiple month's work with upgrading the airframe and repainting if I'm going to be disappointed compared to the FL 1600. I'd just buy another 1600 and accept the slight size difference.

    Thanks for your input....
    is the 1600mm really that much night-and-day better out of the box, or does the FMS 1700 still hold its own once dialed in?

    Leave a comment:


  • Hugh Wiedman
    replied
    Originally posted by davegee
    Click image for larger version Name:	IMG_4022.jpg Views:	0 Size:	144.0 KB ID:	453326 Click image for larger version Name:	IMG_4023.jpg Views:	0 Size:	176.4 KB ID:	453327 Click image for larger version Name:	IMG_4018.jpg Views:	0 Size:	43.6 KB ID:	453328 Click image for larger version Name:	IMG_4021.jpg Views:	0 Size:	233.0 KB ID:	453329

    Thanks, Rex. Had a good test of the lightweight bombs this morning with two flights and two drops. It went beautifully! I put a carriage bolt weight in the nose for stablility, and it worked great. Both bombs released cleanly and dropped in a perfect ballistic arc to the ground. I could only glance where they landed as I was busy flying the airplane, but once I landed I looked for them.

    It was harder than I thought it would be. One was found somewhat clearly in the brush, but another one had burrowed its way into a sagebrush and it was barely visible to find. I figured it would be close to the other one so I made a slow, expanding circle search and found it.

    No damage really to either bomb from the two drops, but one of the E6000 glue joints separated a bit at the point between the tail fins and the center body section. I still flew it like that for the second flight and no further issues. It is now gluing up for the next test. I could have flown these all day if I wanted to.

    Here's some pics from this morning. This was the 46th flight of my great HHH P-51D.

    Cheers

    Davegee
    Outstanding Dave!!!!

    You should be working for the War Department!

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_4022.jpg Views:	0 Size:	144.0 KB ID:	453326 Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_4023.jpg Views:	0 Size:	176.4 KB ID:	453327 Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_4018.jpg Views:	0 Size:	43.6 KB ID:	453328 Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_4021.jpg Views:	0 Size:	233.0 KB ID:	453329
    Originally posted by jetfool
    Nice work Dave. Good luck tomorrow. Rex
    Thanks, Rex. Had a good test of the lightweight bombs this morning with two flights and two drops. It went beautifully! I put a carriage bolt weight in the nose for stablility, and it worked great. Both bombs released cleanly and dropped in a perfect ballistic arc to the ground. I could only glance where they landed as I was busy flying the airplane, but once I landed I looked for them.

    It was harder than I thought it would be. One was found somewhat clearly in the brush, but another one had burrowed its way into a sagebrush and it was barely visible to find. I figured it would be close to the other one so I made a slow, expanding circle search and found it.

    No damage really to either bomb from the two drops, but one of the E6000 glue joints separated a bit at the point between the tail fins and the center body section. I still flew it like that for the second flight and no further issues. It is now gluing up for the next test. I could have flown these all day if I wanted to.

    Here's some pics from this morning. This was the 46th flight of my great HHH P-51D.

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • jetfool
    replied
    Nice work Dave. Good luck tomorrow. Rex

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    I've been working on a way to lighten up the load of bombs/drop tanks on my Flightline 1600mm P-51D Hurry Home Honey. The PLA bombs I printed and have successfully flown and dropped on flights were good and realistic, but the hard desert floor we have here in NW Wyoming is very hard on things that go bump in the night. Sometimes they come back without a scratch, sometimes damaged on impact but usually repairable, and sometimes they just go missing and not found again.

    Elbee clued me in to a filament called TPU, a type of Polyurethane mix that is very flexible and more resistant to damage when they hit the hard ground., in theory. I have had some problems working with some of the larger parts I have printed in TPU, but did manage to make two simulated 500# bombs and have tested the finished prototypes on the bench for drop testing this afternoon. TPU hopefully will be very impact resistant, but it is not as well and cleanly printed as are other filaments like PLA. But then, these bombs are strictly for demonstrating successful dropping from a model airplane at altitude, and not for up close inspection. The others I have already printed and flown in some cases are the ones to show for static viewing.

    If weather is good tomorrow morning, I'm going to try at least one drop test with them, possibly two and see how they survive, if they DO survive. Should be an interesting test. If this goes well, I'll print up the larger scale 110 gallon drop tanks that have flown printed in the heavier and more fragile and stiff PLA material.

    Below are a couple pics of my work in the past couple of days. One pic shows the under-development TPU bombs (silver) with two earlier PLA bombs. The other photo shows the TPU bombs painted as I will fly them tomorrow. I had to open a slit in the bombs so that they could slide into the stock Flightline wing pylon. The material of the bomb is so thin that it is very pliable but fits well onto the pylon and does well in drop tests on the bench today. They are substantially lighter than the PLA bombs, weighing under 2 ounces each.

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_4017.jpg
Views:	241
Size:	143.1 KB
ID:	453315 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_4018.jpg
Views:	235
Size:	43.6 KB
ID:	453316

    Leave a comment:


  • Hugh Wiedman
    replied
    Sorry I'm infecting this FW 1600mm P-51 thread with talk of the flying brick FMS 1700mm P-51.

    What this really shows is how superb the Flightline 1600mm P-51 really is. The competition can't touch it. Looks awesome and is powered perfectly, even sporting a 4 blade prop. Anyone looking for a large P-51 would be a fool not to have it at the top of their list!

    Leave a comment:


  • Hugh Wiedman
    replied

    Leave a comment:


  • Hugh Wiedman
    replied
    Originally posted by nickwildman81
    Hello chaps! Looking for some advice... I have the Flightline P51 operational, and I also have a FMS 1700 P51 as a project. A complete airframe, never flown, and a comprehensive set of spare parts, but I'm intending to upgrade to nylon hinges and ball links, custom paint and decals, etc.

    However, I recently conducted a maiden on my FMS 1700 V3 Corsair, and it's really underpowered (I was aware) to the point that where I'm going to have to upgrade the power system if I want to fly scale-like airshow routines, as it just doesn't have enough 'umff'.

    I'm now hesitant to put in all the work that I planned, into the FMS 1700 P51, if I'm going to be constantly comparing its performance to the brilliant Flightline 1600.

    So, a couple of questions - I've noted a number of you have, or have had, the FMS 1700. I'm not into modifying this, modifying that, sourcing this, sourcing that, but would be willing to upgrade the power system, retaining a 4 blade prop, if it's going to give me comparable (doesn't have too be exact) performance to the 1600, so that I can fly scale-like large loops and an airshow routine for example.

    The Flightline power system and prop has been suggested to me. I believe someone has installed an Elite 60 but required a 2 blade prop or extensive hub modification, which I can't be bothered with.

    So the final question is... am I always going to be comparing the 1700 with the 1600, and be disappointed even after installing a more powerful motor? Should I sell the 1700 in its entirety, with spare parts, and just buy another 1600 instead?

    I don't want to put in multiple month's work with upgrading the airframe and repainting if I'm going to be disappointed compared to the FL 1600. I'd just buy another 1600 and accept the slight size difference.

    Thanks for your input....
    Go to my post in this thread from around July 20th, I think Mr. Mulligan Upgraded the motor, now flies awesome. Also detailed in the RC Groups thread specifically for the FMS 1700 P-51.

    Here's my flight video:

    Leave a comment:


  • paulrkytek
    replied
    Originally posted by JackTBear
    I fly mostly 1500-1700mm warbirds and a few EDF jets. Many Flightline and FMS planes in the hangar, I fly them scale and enjoy them all. This new 1600mm P-51, other than the small prop, is great looking, however it is sluggish, never feels locked in and is generally boring to fly. I understand they wanted to dumb it down and make it easier to fly but it's a little too dumbed down for me. Compared to my E-Flite P-51 1500mm it's no contest, the E-Flite is far more agile and entertaining to fly. Am I alone in this appraisal? Am I missing something?
    Probably not. My Flightline Spitfire is 650gms lighter take off weight, same motor, same wing area, (77gms/dm2 as opposed to 90gms/dm2 with Mustang )flies lighter, more agile than the Mustang. I bought the Mustang to replace my old 1450mm Mustang which after several years of service finally bit the dust. I used it for spot landing competitions at the local club and even added a double bomb/wing tank drop for the target event. Yes the Mustang 1600 flies scale but not as entertaining or graceful as my Spitfire. Adding "improvements" adds weight, alters flight envelope and warrants more power which to me it does not have . Out of choice I take the Spitfire out to fly first, I guess it is a question of what you want out of the model on the day and how Freewing intended it to fly.

    Leave a comment:


  • JackTBear
    replied
    I fly mostly 1500-1700mm warbirds and a few EDF jets. Many Flightline and FMS planes in the hangar, I fly them scale and enjoy them all. This new 1600mm P-51, other than the small prop, is great looking, however it is sluggish, never feels locked in and is generally boring to fly. I understand they wanted to dumb it down and make it easier to fly but it's a little too dumbed down for me. Compared to my E-Flite P-51 1500mm it's no contest, the E-Flite is far more agile and entertaining to fly. Am I alone in this appraisal? Am I missing something?

    Leave a comment:


  • paulrkytek
    replied
    Originally posted by nickwildman81
    Hello chaps! Looking for some advice... I have the Flightline P51 operational, and I also have a FMS 1700 P51 as a project. A complete airframe, never flown, and a comprehensive set of spare parts, but I'm intending to upgrade to nylon hinges and ball links, custom paint and decals, etc.

    However, I recently conducted a maiden on my FMS 1700 V3 Corsair, and it's really underpowered (I was aware) to the point that where I'm going to have to upgrade the power system if I want to fly scale-like airshow routines, as it just doesn't have enough 'umff'.

    I'm now hesitant to put in all the work that I planned, into the FMS 1700 P51, if I'm going to be constantly comparing its performance to the brilliant Flightline 1600.

    So, a couple of questions - I've noted a number of you have, or have had, the FMS 1700. I'm not into modifying this, modifying that, sourcing this, sourcing that, but would be willing to upgrade the power system, retaining a 4 blade prop, if it's going to give me comparable (doesn't have too be exact) performance to the 1600, so that I can fly scale-like large loops and an airshow routine for example.

    The Flightline power system and prop has been suggested to me. I believe someone has installed an Elite 60 but required a 2 blade prop or extensive hub modification, which I can't be bothered with.

    So the final question is... am I always going to be comparing the 1700 with the 1600, and be disappointed even after installing a more powerful motor? Should I sell the 1700 in its entirety, with spare parts, and just buy another 1600 instead?

    I don't want to put in multiple month's work with upgrading the airframe and repainting if I'm going to be disappointed compared to the FL 1600. I'd just buy another 1600 and accept the slight size difference.

    Thanks for your input....
    Assuming you do not have the Flightline 1600 Spitfire I would buy one instead of a second Mustang 1600 and sell the FMS 1700 to avoid the hassle and disappoint of the older FMS airframe. The Spitfire is cheaper than the Mustang and to me flies better.

    Leave a comment:


  • Grossman56
    replied
    I've heard several comments on the 1700mm Mustang about its under performance. I seem to recall someone trying an 8s battery, that might be an easy fix, I'd have someone with experience with this bird give more comprehensive advice.
    Check this out:
    I recently purchased the FMS 1700mm P-51D Red tail. Its a beautiful scale airplane but just lacks power. I dont need a pylon racer but some realistic vertical


    Grossman56
    (Dangerous Dan)

    Leave a comment:


  • nickwildman81
    replied
    Hello chaps! Looking for some advice... I have the Flightline P51 operational, and I also have a FMS 1700 P51 as a project. A complete airframe, never flown, and a comprehensive set of spare parts, but I'm intending to upgrade to nylon hinges and ball links, custom paint and decals, etc.

    However, I recently conducted a maiden on my FMS 1700 V3 Corsair, and it's really underpowered (I was aware) to the point that where I'm going to have to upgrade the power system if I want to fly scale-like airshow routines, as it just doesn't have enough 'umff'.

    I'm now hesitant to put in all the work that I planned, into the FMS 1700 P51, if I'm going to be constantly comparing its performance to the brilliant Flightline 1600.

    So, a couple of questions - I've noted a number of you have, or have had, the FMS 1700. I'm not into modifying this, modifying that, sourcing this, sourcing that, but would be willing to upgrade the power system, retaining a 4 blade prop, if it's going to give me comparable (doesn't have too be exact) performance to the 1600, so that I can fly scale-like large loops and an airshow routine for example.

    The Flightline power system and prop has been suggested to me. I believe someone has installed an Elite 60 but required a 2 blade prop or extensive hub modification, which I can't be bothered with.

    So the final question is... am I always going to be comparing the 1700 with the 1600, and be disappointed even after installing a more powerful motor? Should I sell the 1700 in its entirety, with spare parts, and just buy another 1600 instead?

    I don't want to put in multiple month's work with upgrading the airframe and repainting if I'm going to be disappointed compared to the FL 1600. I'd just buy another 1600 and accept the slight size difference.

    Thanks for your input....

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by Elbee

    Dave,

    With the added flexibility and 20% infill the wall thickness can be reduced.

    That will decrease the weight more than the material itself.

    This is always a compromise.

    Do you still have some of the LW-PLA?

    You could try test printing the tanks with that also.

    Best, Steve
    Thanks, Steve. I do have almost the complete roll of the LW-PLA. I tried a couple small projects with it but it turned out exactly the same weight as an identical test object that was regular PLA. I'm sure it must have been operator error. I thought I had the temp high enough, I think around 230 degrees C to activate the processes of the lightweight filament, but never got that far with it. It's still stored next to my printer.

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • Elbee
    replied
    Originally posted by davegee

    Great info, Thanks! This was a brand I had not heard of before offered on Amazon, but hopefully it will work. Worth a try. The biggest breakthrough is if it is considerably lighter than the ones I have printed, which are excellent, but lighter is always good when flying these prototypes. I'm expecting the spool to arrive late next week and then I can go to work on a couple of small test projects..

    Cheers

    Davegee
    Dave,

    With the added flexibility and 20% infill the wall thickness can be reduced.

    That will decrease the weight more than the material itself.

    This is always a compromise.

    Do you still have some of the LW-PLA?

    You could try test printing the tanks with that also.

    Best, Steve

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by Elbee

    Dave,

    Flexible filaments like TPU should be printed at higher temperatures.

    230C is good starting point and you can reduce temps from there.

    Depending on the brand you bought, there might be a print guide included with the filament.

    I have added a link to a website I have used that explains some do's and don'ts.

    Your design should have a wall thickness of at least 2mm with an infill of 20%.

    I would use Support Cubic as the infill for your first print and see if it is stiff enough to withstand the drops.

    Stringing will be an issue, but is easily removed.

    These prints won't be perfect like PLA, but should last much longer in use.

    Best, Steve
    Great info, Thanks! This was a brand I had not heard of before offered on Amazon, but hopefully it will work. Worth a try. The biggest breakthrough is if it is considerably lighter than the ones I have printed, which are excellent, but lighter is always good when flying these prototypes. I'm expecting the spool to arrive late next week and then I can go to work on a couple of small test projects..

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:

Working...