Official FlightLine 1600mm P-51D Mustang Thread

Collapse
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by Elbee

    Dan,

    What is the all finished weight including paint?

    Where is the tank's CoG point, i.e., is it located at/near the aircraft's CoG?

    Best, LB
    Hi LB: I don't think Dan knows of this one since the actual printing and assembly work has been done at my shop. The finished and painted tanks weigh about 6.5 oz each. The previous larger drop tanks that would break on landing were about 5.5 oz each. These are definiitely more scale and streamlined. There was never a problem flying with the earlier tanks, but I can salvo the new drop tanks at any time if I detect any issue with them.

    The CG has been moved by changing the position of the pylon connect point to the tank. Both tanks are right at the airplane CG, at the manufacturer's recommended mark printed on the bottom of the wing.

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • Elbee
    replied
    Originally posted by Grossman56
    These have been a challenge for sure. We realized that (uniquely for these large flying pieces) you have to take into account their CG and how that aligns with the aircraft's CG. The walls are now 3.0mm thick and the ring thicknesses (the pieces that allow the fore and aft sections to mount on the center section)have been reduced in thickness substantially as well. (Note, I said learning, not learing, hey I'm edjemucated!)

    Grossman56
    (Dangerous Dan)
    Dan,

    What is the all finished weight including paint?

    Where is the tank's CoG point, i.e., is it located at/near the aircraft's CoG?

    Best, LB

    Leave a comment:


  • Grossman56
    replied
    These have been a challenge for sure. We realized that (uniquely for these large flying pieces) you have to take into account their CG and how that aligns with the aircraft's CG. The walls are now 3.0mm thick and the ring thicknesses (the pieces that allow the fore and aft sections to mount on the center section)have been reduced in thickness substantially as well.
    Click image for larger version  Name:	Screenshot 2026-09-05 152250.png Views:	0 Size:	86.7 KB ID:	452578
    It's a trade off between strength and weight a fine balancing act, but the learning curve went way up with this project Click image for larger version  Name:	Screenshot 2026-09-03 183240a.png Views:	0 Size:	21.8 KB ID:	452579
    (Note, I said learning, not learing, hey I'm edjemucated!)

    Grossman56
    (Dangerous Dan)

    Leave a comment:


  • Elbee
    commented on 's reply
    I sent you a tali wheel for one of your projects. That was printed with TPU, but not the foaming variant. However, that can be printed at a higher temp to change its' viscocities. LWPLA would be a decent choice, though you need to print at a heigher temp to get the benefits of the foaming action. The distinction is some products are pre-foamed and some you choose the amount of foaming by print temperature. Id you didn't have much luck with the LWPLA change the design. You can print thin walls with differing infill patterns and achieve strenghth and light weight. It is definately a learn as you go process. There's going to be a compromise between scale fidelity and something you can drop more than once or twice without breking the part.

  • davegee
    replied
    Thanks, Elbee. I'm not familiar with TPU. I did try Color Fabb LW-PLA on a different project about a year ago, but I didn't have much luck with reducing weight. In fact, it was the same weight as regular PLA. Probably operator error.

    I'll check into it (TPU). As soon as the wind dies down, whenever that occurs this week, I plan on flying HHH and see how these latest test flights go. Do you know of a good vendor for picking up a spool of it to try?

    Thanks,

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by nuts-n-volts
    Dave, I really don't know much about 3dp (I don't own one), but I was wondering... Would the material used for tires work? If the tanks were rubbery, they may take a hit better than if they are stiff.
    It's a moving and developing target. Might be a possibility to look into.

    Thanks,

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • Elbee
    commented on 's reply
    The material TPU is what you're thinking of and depending on whether you use the foaming variant or the pre-foamed variant your results vary by the temperature parts are printed.those would also be super lightweight. The surface quality can be porous looking, so any post processing adds weight. I would try it in a heartbeat.

  • nuts-n-volts
    replied
    Dave, I really don't know much about 3dp (I don't own one), but I was wondering... Would the material used for tires work? If the tanks were rubbery, they may take a hit better than if they are stiff.

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    "On the Shoulders of Giants"...

    Been working hard on coming up with a droppable, scale 110 gallon tank that can be released in the air and come down (hopefully) undamaged. There have been several test iterations of this concept recently, starting with tanks that were carried and dropped successfully, but were too large for scale. That has been corrected, and Dan and I working together, him on the computer designing these parts, and me printing, testing, and putting them together for eventual flying. We're not there quite yet, but I hope to do a test fly and drop later this week with P-51D HHH.Finally got the CG of the long and fairly heavy tanks to line up with the CG of the wing. That was no small accomplishment. We'll see when we do taxi and hopefully flight tests how they do. We take heed from lessons learned with each disappointment or failure. That helps develop better results later.

    Below is a picture of the various iterations in test that we have been working on. In the back are parts of the original "too large" tanks, and in the foreground is the current test article along with a twin being fabricated now will try the taxi/flight test drops later this week. The reason for the mulitlple colors of the tank, is that I ran out of my preferred silver filament, and had to do with what I had lying around until a replacenent spool comes today. (they'll all get a grey primer and silver coat, anyway!) But we got the weight down substantially by a couple of ounces or more by thinning the walls as much as possible and I"m hopeful they'll be successful this week.

    Assuming that goes well, continued testing in the shop and in flight, and then painting and detailing for the final product.

    Back to the workshop!

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_3947.jpg Views:	0 Size:	160.9 KB ID:	452558

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by Grossman56
    Now I have to somehow get my hands on one of these planes so I can hang a set on my own!!
    Hi Dan: I have been looking into another idea on the tanks. My CG for the V3A tanks is too far aft. I'm thinking with your new lightened tank parts, if I move the slot on the tank back about .75"-1" it will align closer to the airplane's actual CG which has a manufacturer's mark on the bottom of the wing. This would also take a lot of the strain off the downward movement of the aft part of the tank that I experienced today. This would allow the single connector on the pylon maybe to hold the tank in place, instead of it falling off during taxi trials. That's what I'm thinking, anyway.

    When you get the new lightened parts finished, send them to my gmail and I'll print them up, make the slot for the tank to pylon aft about .75 inches or so, and see if we can get the tank CG and the airplane's CG to get pretty close together. That might be the secret to getting these large drop tanks to work like we want them to!

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • Grossman56
    replied
    Now I have to somehow get my hands on one of these planes so I can hang a set on my own!!

    Leave a comment:


  • Grossman56
    replied
    Hi guys, let me chime in here.
    I went over the tank and reduced the wall thickness in the center section from 3.5mm to 2.0mm then reduced the reinforcing in the nose and tail by half.
    The one thing that either of us didn't consider was the CG of the tank itself, which could cause some of the problem when you get into such relatively large pieces.
    Anyway, the V3A Light will look and fit together exactly the same, so we'll see what the weight comes out as.
    I'll say one thing, they look freaking AWESOME! if I do say so myself, I've only seen the design but to physically see my creation is just such a thrill!

    Grossman56
    (Dangerous Dan)

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by jetfool
    Davegee,
    If you could determine how the tanks are landing(hitting the dirt) you might be able to make those aeras strong and less in the non-crucial area. Just my .02.
    I'm sure with all the Edwards high tech cameras, your technician (Lt. Dan) and you will figure the problem out.
    Best Regards, Rex
    Good point. The weak points were when they landed on one end or the other. That caused breakage of the tank at that point. We went in with reinforcing those forward and end piece cones internally, and I'm hoping that will fix that problem. It they land flat, they usually aren't damaged.

    The main issue right now is the OEM wing mounts that we hang the ordnance on. There is a clip at the forward end of the wing mount, and that is the only place that keeps the bomb or tank attached to the plane. That is no problem for the very light OEM teardrop-shaped foam tanks and the 500 pound bombs I printed up which are much lighter and smaller, but the big 110 gallon tanks like I tried today are very long, and attaching to that single mount way in the front portion of the tank. It's just too much for that mount to hang onto the bar on the bomb or drop tank to keep it attached until commanded to release.

    Weight (of the large drop tank) is definitely a problem right now. The OEM wing mount is really well designed, for lightweight ordnance. But I'm going to work on a lighterweight version of the big tank, and that would be a solution, I think. I'm very happy how the actual tank came out, and it could always be a static display, or attached to the wing mount so it flies with the plane without dropping inflight. Lots of possibilites. But I still hope to get it to work.

    Thanks for your input, always appreciated!

    Cheers

    davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • jetfool
    replied
    Davegee,
    If you could determine how the tanks are landing(hitting the dirt) you might be able to make those aeras strong and less in the non-crucial area. Just my .02.
    I'm sure with all the Edwards high tech cameras, your technician (Lt. Dan) and you will figure the problem out.
    Best Regards, Rex

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    I took HHH out to the field to hopefully test fly the new printed 110 gallon drop tanks this morning. Weather was beautiful. The tanks came out very well, I think. Dan Gross did a sterling job with the design and I was able to get them ready for mounting to the airplane. I use the same mounts that the OEM 75 gallon foam drop tanks and the 500 pound bombs that I printed up from an STL that I bought.

    Unfortunately, after doing a series of test taxi runs up and down the runway with them attached, one tank would stay on ok, but the other one would drop off whenever I went over a small crack or bump in the runway. I tried a few ideas using a bit of masking tape to make a little better fit so they would stay on, but they were just too heavy. They weigh slightly over 8 oz. each, and the OEM drop mounts on the wings just aren't up to holding that heavy a weight.

    I decided I had to "punt" using the present setup. What would be ideal would be a custom foam scale tank and that would work fine. Possibly even making them with thinner walls might take enough weight off of them that caused the problems this morning, but then you have problems with damage when they hit the hard ground.

    So, I have the correct size, a well -designed and accurate drop tank, and maybe I can come up with another solution for getting a lighter version of these tanks to be able to be dropped in flight to a safe landing. I'll attach some pics at the field this morning. After I decided a test flight with these tanks that could very well come loose in flight and spell disaster, I did a couple of flights without any ordnance for some fun. It is a great flyer!

    Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_3936.jpg Views:	0 Size:	205.6 KB ID:	452481 Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_3943 (1).jpg Views:	0 Size:	168.9 KB ID:	452482 Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_3941.jpg Views:	0 Size:	224.0 KB ID:	452483

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by jetfool
    Davegee and Dan,
    Believe you guys hit the nail on the head. Fantastic realism.
    Rex
    Thanks, Rex. Assuming it comes through the drop tests in better shape than the previous larger iterations, I'll start working on detailing them and adding air and fuel lines to make it look more realistic. They won't have any true function, other than scale and glitz, but that should finish up this project, when done. I'm still considering getting an extra canopy and adding that detailed cockpit kit, but haven't totally decided on that yet. I'd probably still fly the present setup but use the detailed cockpit for ground display. We'll see...

    Below is a real photo of a contemporary P-51D showing the air and fuel lines that connect the 110 gallon drop tanks to the wing tank. The second picture, (taken upside down) is the same scale tubing and a printed 110 gallon tank that was, and is, part of a display at the Mighty Eighth Air Force Museum in Pooler, GA, near Savannah. That model is a 1:4.5 scale CARF kit. The person that fabricated the 3D tank was the most incredible 3D modeler I have ever come across, and this he did in 2018! He worked for a government contractor and did all sorts of classified and non-classified projects for the govt. I built and painted the plane and did the detail work of the plumbing for the tanks and airplane. The small section of clear tubing on the model represents glass tubing that was used to ensure that they got a clean separation of the tank from the wing when they had to punch them off in combat situations. Mine is just clear flexible vinyl tubing for that part. The real airplane in the photo didn't go to that level of detail, I guess.

    Click image for larger version  Name:	images (2).jpg Views:	0 Size:	42.8 KB ID:	452465 Click image for larger version  Name:	Photo_2026-08-12_140547.jpg Views:	0 Size:	133.4 KB ID:	452466

    Leave a comment:


  • jetfool
    replied
    Davegee and Dan,
    Believe you guys hit the nail on the head. Fantastic realism.
    Rex

    Leave a comment:


  • Grossman56
    replied
    looking at our new iteration versus the pic of the real deal, it looks pretty darned good!
    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_3934.jpg
Views:	163
Size:	177.5 KB
ID:	452450 Click image for larger version

Name:	476805720_599901309697865_3138355611978750624_n.jpg
Views:	149
Size:	191.9 KB
ID:	452451
    I'm liking it!

    Grossman5
    (Dangerous Dan)

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by nuts-n-volts
    Dave, 1st, those new tanks are looking spot on! Great work and I hope, think they will survive the ultimate drop test.

    2nd Thank-you for the kind words. But even without those, I am always glad to help... anyone. ...I love the Mustang.
    I thought you and maybe others might enjoy a link I found to Major Richard "Pete" Peterson and the 357th FG in WWII. Some good photos in there. Here is the link for those interested: https://toflyandfight.com/tribute-to...rd-a-peterson/

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by nuts-n-volts
    Dave, 1st, those new tanks are looking spot on! Great work and I hope, think they will survive the ultimate drop test.

    2nd Thank-you for the kind words. But even without those, I am always glad to help... anyone. ...I love the Mustang.
    Thanks, Nuts-n-Volts. You have helped me with suggestions in the past that worked out well. I appreciate your knowledge base and take heed when you make a suggestion! I'm not sure where we got the 3 1/2" diameter for the 110 gallon tank in 1/7 scale, possibly it came from a diecast or plastic model kit and something got lost in translation. At any rate, they are the correct size now, thanks to you, and even if they break up on ground impact, I can easily print up new ones, or at least know I got this one right.

    The 357th FG did a lot of bomber escort missions deep into Germany, and these tanks were key to allowing the P-51s to stay with their bombers all the way to target and back. I'm glad I made these up, not only for the fun and challenge of modeling, but to also show others that these were an integral part of the missions that they and other fighter units flew in WWII.

    I"ll report back no matter what happens when I do the drop test of these tanks probably later this week.

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:

Working...