Roban - World Class Scale Helicopters

Official FlightLine 1600mm P-51D Mustang Thread

Collapse
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • nuts-n-volts
    replied
    Dave, 1st, those new tanks are looking spot on! Great work and I hope, think they will survive the ultimate drop test.

    2nd Thank-you for the kind words. But even without those, I am always glad to help... anyone. ...I love the Mustang.

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by nuts-n-volts
    Click image for larger version

Name:	476805720_599901309697865_3138355611978750624_n.jpg
Views:	246
Size:	135.6 KB
ID:	452214 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_3902.jpg
Views:	260
Size:	243.3 KB
ID:	452213
    Dave, I was just wondering from your latest photo if your tanks aren't a tad too big in diameter?
    Nuts-n-Volts made an astute observation when Danger Dan and I put some of the 110 gallon drop tanks together in a 3D printed form. They flew fine three times, but were weak when landing on the ground and usually fractured. Nuts-n-Volts observed that the diameter, not the length, looked a bit too big. I hadn't even considered that, but when he mentioned it, I looked at it more closely and then measured the tanks. Mine were too large by 1/2 inch in diameter at the "fattest" part. They should have been 3 inches in diameter and 14.28 inches long, for 1/7 scale that the Flightline 1.6M P-51D is. They were actually 3 1/2 inches in diameter, and that makes a Big difference!

    So, Dan made me some adjusted tanks that are now spot on, dimensionswise. I did some testing in my shop just now and have the tanks loosely put together with tape, and tested CG with the tanks on and off, and seeing how well they drop away from the airplane onto foam cushions on my work table. Everything worked out great. So, I will run a few more tests and weather permitting, I'll do a drop test with these tanks. I won't bother to paint them or put the final details on them until I know that they will survive the drop to the ground, but I am encouraged that their thicker shells will keep them from breaking. We'll see.

    I'll attach some pics. On the CG tests, I decided to move the battery forward on its tray about 1/2 inch when the tanks are on. This is because the CG of the tanks when attached to the airplane is about 1 inch behind the markings on the wing by the manufacturer. They balance great there. And when I tested the CG with the tanks off, the slightly forward CG is not a problem in the balancing of the airplane after the tanks are released and the plane brought back in for a landing.

    Kudos to Nuts-n-Volts for pointing out my error on the original tanks, and I think these will look better and more scale. Besides, it was a fun exericse in modeling!

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_3934.jpg
Views:	190
Size:	124.6 KB
ID:	452436 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_3933.jpg
Views:	170
Size:	133.8 KB
ID:	452437 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_3932.jpg
Views:	160
Size:	141.0 KB
ID:	452438

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by nuts-n-volts
    I wanted to add that your HHH looks magnificent!
    Thanks so much, Nuts-n-Volts! The current setup printing I have done works out fine, but the drop tanks just can't take the brunt of hitting the hard desert ground. However, the earlier rectangular drop tank designed by Dan Gross and then fabricated by Craft Cloud was more than up to the task of surviving the drop to the ground to reuse the tank again and again. It was tested again yesterday on my FMS P-47D Hairless Joe and it worked great.

    So, I hope to work with Dan to make the corrections to the STL that you brought up about the diameter of the tank and a couple of other minor tweaks, Craft Cloud can print up a few of them and we can be assured they will survive the demonstration drop.

    I appreciate your observations on the too-large diameter of the tank we came up with, and that was very helpful to changing this to look exactly the way we want it to, and properly in scale as well. When you pointed that out, I had to agree with you that it needs a little adjustment.

    Take care,

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • nuts-n-volts
    replied
    I wanted to add that your HHH looks magnificent!

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Hi Nuts-n- Volts: I did check the size of those 110 gallon tanks that we fabricated. The Flightline P-51D 1.6M airplane is 1/7 scale. The real 110 gallon drop tanks were about 100 inches long and 21 inches in diameter. My model tank is 14.4 inches long (versus real scale 14.28 inches long) and mine is 3.3 inches in diameter at the widest part (versus 3 inches for the real thing in 1/7 scale.) So it is slightly larger than scale. I think it might have "grown" a bit during our planning but it's not terribly far off. If we get some printed, we'll make sure they are 3 inches in diameter and about 14.3 inches long, per scale.

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by nuts-n-volts
    Click image for larger version

Name:	476805720_599901309697865_3138355611978750624_n.jpg
Views:	246
Size:	135.6 KB
ID:	452214 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_3902.jpg
Views:	260
Size:	243.3 KB
ID:	452213
    Dave, I was just wondering from your latest photo if your tanks aren't a tad too big in diameter?
    Good question. We took measurements from a accurate model that had these tanks, and that's what they were when scaled up. But that will be one of the things we'll revisit to be sure they are the correct size before we proceed further. They do look a bit oversized when compared to your pic.

    Thanks for the input, we'll examine this to see how to proceed on with this project. A bit smaller would be good as less drag and less weight.

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • nuts-n-volts
    replied
    Click image for larger version

Name:	476805720_599901309697865_3138355611978750624_n.jpg
Views:	246
Size:	135.6 KB
ID:	452214 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_3902.jpg
Views:	260
Size:	243.3 KB
ID:	452213
    Dave, I was just wondering from your latest photo if your tanks aren't a tad too big in diameter?

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by jetfool
    Davegee,
    I've been flying a lot and little shop time. Will get back on the Phantom this fall for Toledo 27. Kinda ran out of workshop steam last March. I plan to test fly my P-47 and FL P-38 in the next few weeks. I have them set up on my new Specktrum 8+ and have been flying a E-Flite Air Tractor 1.5m to get used to the new radio. Bought the Air Tractor July 4 and have 40 flights on it. I am keeping up on your progress weekly.
    Hope FL introduces some new Warbirds 1.6m this year. Not real interested in the small one, hard to see for me.
    A friend of mine is learning to fly EDF jets and in 4 weeks totaled out 2 and just orders another one. On his 3rd one in 4 weeks. Wish I had his money(he's still working for his hobby money)
    Best Regards, Rex
    Good deal. For your Phantom, would you be interested in printed missiles for the bottom of the fuselage? I had these on my F-4 for many years until it crashed years ago. I can send you a pic PM if you are interested. They fit into the grooves on the bottom of the fuse with magnets. If you don't want them that's fine. But I can send them to you for free if you do. Otherwise, I'll probably just throw them out. They look good, I think. I think one is missing a small fin but that would be easy to replace with styrene plastic cut to fit.

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • jetfool
    replied
    Davegee,
    I've been flying a lot and little shop time. Will get back on the Phantom this fall for Toledo 27. Kinda ran out of workshop steam last March. I plan to test fly my P-47 and FL P-38 in the next few weeks. I have them set up on my new Specktrum 8+ and have been flying a E-Flite Air Tractor 1.5m to get used to the new radio. Bought the Air Tractor July 4 and have 40 flights on it. I am keeping up on your progress weekly.
    Hope FL introduces some new Warbirds 1.6m this year. Not real interested in the small one, hard to see for me.
    A friend of mine is learning to fly EDF jets and in 4 weeks totaled out 2 and just orders another one. On his 3rd one in 4 weeks. Wish I had his money(he's still working for his hobby money)
    Best Regards, Rex

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by jetfool
    Great Job Mr. Beta Tester! You will get it figured out. Rex
    Hi Rex: great to see you online again. Haven’t seen any of your posts for a little while. These tanks, especially the larger 110 gallon models are a process. The only problem remaining is keeping them from getting damaged or destroyed upon landing on “Mars. “ (My wife and I joke how hard and tough the ground is here, with very little moisture.) I’m thinking I might have CraftCloud make a couple from Dan’s STLs like we did for the P-47 centerline drop tank. That thing is practically indestructible! If not that method, possibly getting a foam copy fabricated somehow. We’ll see…

    cheers

    davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • f4u ausie
    replied
    The lower leg on the gear. Is a little weak ... Hollow cast... My friend has broken 2 of them.. to be fair he is new to taildrag warbirds.. but I saw one landing and was shocked that it broke

    Leave a comment:


  • jetfool
    replied
    Great Job Mr. Beta Tester! You will get it figured out. Rex

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Took up my HHH Flightline P-51D for drop tests using the printed bombs and then another test dropping the printed 110 gallon tanks that Danger Dan designed. First, The P-51 performed beautifully, and I got my 25th and 26th flights on it this morning wth the drop tests.

    Bomb drop went much better. I set up lawn sprinkler flourescent pink flags on steel wires in the ground in a line to help me orient myself when I wanted to drop the bombs/tanks. This helps as I do this alone and can't divert my attention for more than a second seeing where the bombs/tanks fell, which was right in the area that I wanted to. I also installed an Estes electronic altimeter inside the fuse to get an idea of how high I was flying. The first drop test with the bombs max altitude was 98' above the ground. Second test with the drop tanks, it was 151' max altitude above the ground. Interesting information, for possible future use, I don't know.

    Results: 500# bomb drop worked great, the two bombs landed within 2 feet of each other. No damage.

    110 gallon printed tanks flew captive perfectly, released beautifully and dropped to the ground in a realistic manner. Unfortunately, both tanks were damaged when they hit the ground.
    A couple thoughts: one, I might have Craft Cloud print up some stronger tanks, even after I had reinforced mine in the printing thickness.The one I had them print for the Hairless Joe P-47D was built like a tank, but still light enough for the airplane to handle ok. Another idea would be to find someone who could make me styrofoam tanks, using my printed tanks as a mold to make them. Don't know who would do that, but I think that would work well and be much lighter. If anyone has any leads on someone who could do this, please let me know.

    F-86F flew great, and my repair on the gear door held up well. I've already ordered a couple of spares just because of our tough runway we operate from.

    Below is the test Estes electronic altimeter, which worked beautifully. A pic showing the module after the second flight test, 151 feet altitude.
    Also, a pic shortly before takeoff for the HHH carrying the printed 110 gallon tanks. A new silver section has been added to the right tank. All three parts of that tank were modified for a bit thicker structure. It didn't hold up this time, but there are several options for future tests.

    Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_3905.jpg Views:	0 Size:	48.6 KB ID:	452178 Click image for larger version  Name:	IMG_3902.jpg Views:	0 Size:	170.5 KB ID:	452179


    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by Elbee
    davegee

    More than welcome, Dave.

    In the world of drop tanks and dropping ordnance, I'd just keep printing those even if I didn't think I'd need 'em.

    Best, LB
    Good advice. I printed up two more "bombs" for the ones I lost when I dropped them the other day. Chances are someone will come across them someday, or even if they don't it was easy to print them up, costs next to nothing, just my time. They are amazing to watch how streamlined they are and realistic from WWII videos I have watched. For my B-25, I have about a dozen bombs printed up with weights in the nose, some painted orange, some OD. If I lose one or break one, piece of cake replacing those, too!

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • Elbee
    replied
    davegee

    More than welcome, Dave.

    In the world of drop tanks and dropping ordnance, I'd just keep printing those even if I didn't think I'd need 'em.

    Best, LB

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by davegee
    Thanks, Elbee. It’s mostly the middle cylinder that is weak. I saw this just handling it, almost like an egg shell that could crack if you applied minimal pressure with your fingers.

    I"ll try your suggestions on a new tank. The conical forward and aft ends are quite a bit stronger than the middle. I"ll start working on strengthening the middle section first.

    Cheers

    Davegee
    Hi Elbee: I made the changes on my Prusa menu and the new tank that I printed today feels definitely stronger when I push in on it with my fingers. I have a couple parts I need from MRC first, so within the next couple weeks I should be able to test the V2 model in flight. We'll see what happens. I think if the other one had dropped onto a soft grass field instead of hard packed dirt, rocks, snd sagebrush, I think it might have survived the landing. For whatever reason the other identical drop tank suffered no (zero) damage landing just a few feet away.

    Thanks again for the tip.


    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Thanks, Elbee. It’s mostly the middle cylinder that is weak. I saw this just handling it, almost like an egg shell that could crack if you applied minimal pressure with your fingers.

    I"ll try your suggestions on a new tank. The conical forward and aft ends are quite a bit stronger than the middle. I"ll start working on strengthening the middle section first.

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • Elbee
    replied
    Dave,

    Print those parts (domes) that require infillwith 10-15% Adaptive Cubic Infill in the slicer program.

    Adds decent structure with minimal weight.

    If it is a simple cylinder, increase the wall thickness by a .25mm with each succesive reprint until breakage is no longer an issue.

    Best, LB

    Leave a comment:


  • davegee
    replied
    Originally posted by nuts-n-volts
    But... breaking up is scale!
    Should have filled them with AvGas for the full effect!!

    Cheers

    Davegee

    Leave a comment:


  • nuts-n-volts
    replied
    But... breaking up is scale!

    Leave a comment:

Working...