P-38 - The Ultimate EPO Lightning

Official Freewing T-33 Shooting Star 80mm EDF Thread

Collapse
X
Collapse
First Prev Next Last
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • martinhally
    Member
    • Aug 2023
    • 3
    • Send PM

    #1581
    Hi, I realise this is a very old post and I am new to the forum so this might not be the place to put this post, but after a successful maiden off grass (albeit a very long rollout which surprised mean it was right to the edge) today I sent her up and it was out of control from just after takeoff, I had control then did not , initially I just thought it was a stall i needed to recover from - got to a height and realised I had again lost control and she spiralled into the ground. I fly frisky X20 and flight logs show no loss of signal. So I am going to assume I got hit by a horror in the wiring gremlins - though at crash site everything operated normally - except of course fuselage was broken in two.

    So whilst I await my new fuselage I am going to
    1) wire all controls directly to receiver and the little blue box and wing wire connectors will be gone.
    2) I was going to add a longer front strut to try to get a little more angle of attack suggested in this thread from the L39
    3) I am going to move back the CG from 95mm to 105mm which seemed to be the suggestion too if flying off grass.

    I was also pondering whether to add a separate BEC rather than the one in the ESC - any thoughts as consensus seems to be that the built in BEC is reliable, but the nerves are rattled
    I looked at shortening the rear shocks but there is no a lot of metal to cut so have not done that as yet.

    Anything else anyone cares to suggest to help grass takeoffs and help prevent loss of controls?.

    Receiver is a tandem Frisky, and battery is a 4500 65C

    Comment

    • Elbee
      Be humble...be approachable...and be credible.

      • Feb 2018
      • 4814
      • Wichita, Kansas
      • Send PM

      #1582
      martinhally, Welcome to Hobby Squawk.

      Sorry to read about your incident.

      I have not read anything in quite some time about the E1712 (Blue Box) causing difficulty.

      Your stall debrief seems reasonable, though, gremlins be gremlins, electronic or otherwise.

      I believe your decision to bypass the box for anything but lighting is sound.

      I have done that to my last 3 builds and have encounter no issues I can relate to electronics, other than some twitching servos. (Replace before next flying day).

      Glad to have you onboard, Sir and looking forward to further debrief after your next check flight.

      Best, LB
      "I am having an extraordinary ordinary life."
      ~Lucky B*st*rd~

      "Find satisfaction in the process rather than an outcome."
      ~Anonymous~

      AMA#116446

      Comment

      • timmybeetle
        Warbird addict

        • Jan 2020
        • 132
        • Netherlands
        • Send PM

        #1583
        Martin

        Sad to read you're mishap.
        I flew with the blue box but after reading about issues with it I removed it.
        I also fly Tandem X20 from Frsky with X8R receiver.
        I had one time an issue with my XT90 connector from LIPO with a bad soldering, resulting in loss off control.
        You bought a new fuse, I repaired mine, where to you live??? I would like to repair your fuse because mine is really damaged.....but I live in The Netherlands.
        Mt cg is 15-20mm back from CG marking flying from grass this is a must, also I put a 3-4mm shim under my front retract unit, works great.
        I find this one of the best EDF to fly for me a lot of fun.

        Regards Hans

        ps I use a gyro the NX3 and this really helps with an aft CG, also the T33 flies like a BIG one😉
        Attached Files

        Comment

        • martinhally
          Member
          • Aug 2023
          • 3
          • Send PM

          #1584
          Hans,
          Thanks for the response. That's really helpful information. I was going to move the CG back to 105mm but it sounds like I can go further back safely . I have a longer strut coming which will add 7mm to front height, but I can shim that if I need more!. When it was airborne on my first flight it was awesome, but I need to get it in the sir before end of runway so I think your angle of attack suggestion and CG will help massively. If I am honest I am not a big gyro user - just another thing to go wrong. I may have to change my mind. Better day today as I maddened my a6 Intruder and that was just awesome, off grass no problem - but you can see the angle of attack is up so I am not surprised. Fuselage is wholly intact from wing front back - up front is an absolute mess hence decided a new one was best. rest of plane is unmarked (miracle) I am in Scotland so not sure if it can be sensibly shipped but if so I can post photos of the poor thing. I also had some awesome flights today with my fms 1700mm mustang and my Dynam Gloster meteor (yup a Dynam!!) so a better day than yesterday!

          Comment

          • martinhally
            Member
            • Aug 2023
            • 3
            • Send PM

            #1585
            Apols I am going to have to turn off spell check.

            Comment

            • timmybeetle
              Warbird addict

              • Jan 2020
              • 132
              • Netherlands
              • Send PM

              #1586
              Yesterday I flew as a guest pilot, some nice pics from show.
              Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_0193.jpg
Views:	917
Size:	53.3 KB
ID:	386701

              Grts Hans
              Attached Files

              Comment

              • DCORSAIR
                My R/C addiction started in 1984

                • Jan 2017
                • 1918
                • Selma, Ca.
                • Send PM

                #1587
                Originally posted by timmybeetle
                Yesterday I flew as a guest pilot, some nice pics from show.
                Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_0193.jpg
Views:	917
Size:	53.3 KB
ID:	386701

                Grts Hans
                Nice pics and it looks great in the air, I haven't flown this one yet, going to have to give it a try one day, I had the HSD T-33 and flew it several flights, what a great flyer it is so I bet this one flies great as well.

                Comment

                • wvrailfan
                  HobbySquawk Pilot

                  • Sep 2013
                  • 682
                  • West Virginia
                  • Send PM

                  #1588
                  Is the plastic tube at the rear of the fuselage just for looks or does it help with thrust in some way?

                  I crashed mine and I am replacing the fuse, but the new fuse does not include the small black tube.

                  I can probably salvage the old one, just wondering if it serves a purpose beside appearance?

                  JB​

                  Comment

                  • rjhuyck
                    Member
                    • Oct 2023
                    • 7
                    • Send PM

                    #1589
                    How easy is it to assemble the wing and fuse at the field? If I could separate them it would be easier for transportation to the field. Do most of you just leave it assembled?
                    I just purchased the T-33 last week and haven't put it together yet.

                    Comment

                    • F22trainer
                      Piper PhD

                      • Mar 2018
                      • 1484
                      • Sun City, Az
                      • Send PM

                      #1590
                      Originally posted by rjhuyck
                      How easy is it to assemble the wing and fuse at the field? If I could separate them it would be easier for transportation to the field. Do most of you just leave it assembled?
                      I just purchased the T-33 last week and haven't put it together yet.
                      I used to do that all the time, before I picked up a larger vehicle, and the only inconvenience was the risk of dropping the screws. Be sure to have a good pocket magnet handy.

                      Comment

                      • ggetzoff
                        Member

                        • Jun 2018
                        • 17
                        • Send PM

                        #1591
                        Originally posted by martinhally
                        Hi, I realise this is a very old post and I am new to the forum so this might not be the place to put this post, but after a successful maiden off grass (albeit a very long rollout which surprised mean it was right to the edge) today I sent her up and it was out of control from just after takeoff, I had control then did not , initially I just thought it was a stall i needed to recover from - got to a height and realised I had again lost control and she spiralled into the ground. I fly frisky X20 and flight logs show no loss of signal. So I am going to assume I got hit by a horror in the wiring gremlins - though at crash site everything operated normally - except of course fuselage was broken in two.

                        So whilst I await my new fuselage I am going to
                        1) wire all controls directly to receiver and the little blue box and wing wire connectors will be gone.
                        2) I was going to add a longer front strut to try to get a little more angle of attack suggested in this thread from the L39
                        3) I am going to move back the CG from 95mm to 105mm which seemed to be the suggestion too if flying off grass.

                        I was also pondering whether to add a separate BEC rather than the one in the ESC - any thoughts as consensus seems to be that the built in BEC is reliable, but the nerves are rattled
                        I looked at shortening the rear shocks but there is no a lot of metal to cut so have not done that as yet.

                        Anything else anyone cares to suggest to help grass takeoffs and help prevent loss of controls?.

                        Receiver is a tandem Frisky, and battery is a 4500 65C
                        That sounds like a stall, but of course it may not have been.

                        1. Was the C.G. the same as it was for the crash flight (could the battery have shifted on liftoff?) as for the maiden?

                        2. I bypass the bluebox by just pulling the signal wire from each harness, leaving the power running to the wings / tail section from the blue box.

                        3. Aftermarket BEC is always a good idea.

                        Over the many years of flying RC (and unfortunately full-scale) I have seen a lot of crashes that were simply aft C.G. In this case, the FRSKY didn't show any signal loss, but it could certainly have been a brown-out.

                        Cheers,

                        Greg


                        Comment

                        • rcaviator
                          Member

                          • Nov 2014
                          • 14
                          • Send PM

                          #1592
                          I am considering the T-33 ARF, and putting my FMS 80mm 12 blade 3280-KV2100 EDF and 100 AMP ESC in the plane. The motor came from the FMS BAE Hawk, same motor is used in the 80mm FMS Rafale. Has anyone used this as the replacement for the Freewing 80mm?? Also, can anyone tell me the diameter of the Freewing 80mm lip to lip? Mine is 96mm. It has the same 4 mounting holes as the freewing. If the answer is yes, how much foam needed to be modified to fit?? Thanks. Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_5122.jpg
Views:	777
Size:	110.4 KB
ID:	392733 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_5124.jpg
Views:	671
Size:	92.7 KB
ID:	392734 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_5123.jpg
Views:	681
Size:	90.1 KB
ID:	392735
                          .

                          Comment

                          • rcaviator
                            Member

                            • Nov 2014
                            • 14
                            • Send PM

                            #1593
                            OK...........I bought the T-33 ARF and Installed my FMS 80 mm EDF. It fit almost perfectly. Some minor foam trimming on the bottom, because the FMS case is 3mm longer. Same for the top cover, it requires minor foam trimming for the EDF rim and the case length at the back. In the photos. red indicates where the trimming was required.

                            Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_5130.jpg
Views:	721
Size:	56.7 KB
ID:	392820 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_5133.jpg
Views:	638
Size:	60.8 KB
ID:	392821 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_5132.jpg
Views:	674
Size:	83.2 KB
ID:	392822 Click image for larger version

Name:	IMG_5136.jpg
Views:	670
Size:	104.9 KB
ID:	392823

                            Comment

                            • Elbee
                              Be humble...be approachable...and be credible.

                              • Feb 2018
                              • 4814
                              • Wichita, Kansas
                              • Send PM

                              #1594
                              rcaviator, Nice work, Sir. Best, LB
                              "I am having an extraordinary ordinary life."
                              ~Lucky B*st*rd~

                              "Find satisfaction in the process rather than an outcome."
                              ~Anonymous~

                              AMA#116446

                              Comment

                              • tab28682
                                RC addict

                                • Jul 2017
                                • 334
                                • Fort Worth, TX
                                • Send PM

                                #1595
                                After three years of action, my T-33 needed a refresh. It was looking rough.

                                To make carrying the model easier, I had been suspending it upside down by the main gear. Over time, heat and stress had warped the actual plastic gear mount boxes. Not doing that any more.

                                i dug out the old main gear mounts and installed new ones.

                                Went over the model and did a lot of touch up with spackle and paint. Completely repainted the tip tanks.

                                Looks great now, from about three feet away…..:)

                                Still flies as well today as it did three years and about 120 flights ago!



                                Comment

                                • Elbee
                                  Be humble...be approachable...and be credible.

                                  • Feb 2018
                                  • 4814
                                  • Wichita, Kansas
                                  • Send PM

                                  #1596
                                  tab28682 Good report.
                                  Sometimes a little refreshing is all it takes. I know I feel better after a good refreshening.

                                  Best, LB
                                  "I am having an extraordinary ordinary life."
                                  ~Lucky B*st*rd~

                                  "Find satisfaction in the process rather than an outcome."
                                  ~Anonymous~

                                  AMA#116446

                                  Comment

                                  • HairyTacco
                                    Foam Aficionado

                                    • Dec 2016
                                    • 19
                                    • Canberra, ACT, Australia
                                    • Send PM

                                    #1597
                                    Had a great maiden with the 33 on a very frosty morning.. I added lights from an F14 lightning kit I had lying around. So mine now has nav lights, red anti-col and a landing light on the nose gear.

                                    What an awesome plane in every respect!

                                    She’s a keeper.​

                                    cheers, HTClick image for larger version

Name:	IMG_5328.jpg
Views:	351
Size:	302.1 KB
ID:	405061
                                    Attached Files

                                    Comment

                                    • DCORSAIR
                                      My R/C addiction started in 1984

                                      • Jan 2017
                                      • 1918
                                      • Selma, Ca.
                                      • Send PM

                                      #1598
                                      Originally posted by HairyTacco
                                      Had a great maiden with the 33 on a very frosty morning.. I added lights from an F14 lightning kit I had lying around. So mine now has nav lights, red anti-col and a landing light on the nose gear.

                                      What an awesome plane in every respect!

                                      She’s a keeper.​

                                      cheers, HTClick image for larger version

Name:	IMG_5328.jpg
Views:	351
Size:	302.1 KB
ID:	405061
                                      Looks great, nice pics and I have been trying not to buy this one but after seeing your pics I may just have to get me one, Thanks..

                                      Comment

                                      • Elbee
                                        Be humble...be approachable...and be credible.

                                        • Feb 2018
                                        • 4814
                                        • Wichita, Kansas
                                        • Send PM

                                        #1599
                                        HairyTacco, great mods, beautiful T-33. Best, LB
                                        "I am having an extraordinary ordinary life."
                                        ~Lucky B*st*rd~

                                        "Find satisfaction in the process rather than an outcome."
                                        ~Anonymous~

                                        AMA#116446

                                        Comment

                                        • HairyTacco
                                          Foam Aficionado

                                          • Dec 2016
                                          • 19
                                          • Canberra, ACT, Australia
                                          • Send PM

                                          #1600
                                          Originally posted by DCORSAIR

                                          Looks great, nice pics and I have been trying not to buy this one but after seeing your pics I may just have to get me one, Thanks..
                                          Haha. More than happy to be the facilitator of more RC planes in peoples hangar.

                                          HT

                                          Comment

                                          Working...